Filter Holders

[mummy_leanne]

I'm off to Scotland in October and am expecting there to be plenty of opportunities for landscapes. With that in mind I thought I'd invest in some filters.

Does anyone have any experience with the Hi-Tech filter holders as the built in 105mm ring for CPL filters is quite tempting? Preferably on the Sigma 10-20mm.

If not can anyone recommend the best filter holder to avoid vignettting on this lens?

Am I best off getting the Lee holder and a separate 105mm ring for the times I need a CPL?

Cheers

Leanne

[chimponarope]

Bump for my Mrs.:)

[mummy_leanne]

Ahh well I thought i'd get at least one reply, never mind :(

[instamatic]

Hi. I'm not sure about the vignetting on the lens you mention. I suggest a call to Lee Filters in Andover, or Hi tech, and ask for their technical advice. 10mm is quite wide but it may have been solved already. Sorry can't help more.

[coldpenguin]

Don't know whether we just got sidelined, or came to a conclusion in this thread.
http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=152253&highlight=linear

It is possible that the lee system didn't show the effect too much, or a linear polarizer didn't show a vignette, (apart from mechanical/lens)