PDA

View Full Version : Troublesome child

inophoto
23-06-2007, 21:57
Honest critique requested:

Black and white,

http://static.zooomr.com/images/2516788_d478a57f26.jpg

or Color?

http://static.zooomr.com/images/2516792_8a52e53756.jpg


Interested in your opinions on this one. I can't make my mind up.

ta!
King_Boru
23-06-2007, 21:59
I would go for the color one as the I feel the grey scale has a slight ghostly feeling about it,...?

Lovely capture though, very relaxed, natural and the exposure is spot on!

:-)
moomike
23-06-2007, 22:05
Colour here too (unusual for me with portraits) think you've captured an amazing portrait there & the processing is spot on :clap:
Jonnyreb
23-06-2007, 22:06
I prefer the mono, but as KB states its a little ghostly - maybe try a different filter?
Sherlock_Holmes
23-06-2007, 22:07
No 2:thumbs:
Karen
23-06-2007, 22:07
Colour...the background seems busy in B/W but tones in well in the colour version
inophoto
23-06-2007, 22:10
Thanks!

Super quick responses too :thumbs:
2blue4u
23-06-2007, 22:16
Colour

Colour

Colour

everytime! There's far too much fascination around here with B&W. Sorry if that upsets some people. It's just my opinion. B&W should be reserved for the exceptional 1 in a thousand shot and only then to help bring out the atmosphere.
Jonnyreb
23-06-2007, 22:19
Colour

Colour

Colour

everytime! There's far too much fascination around here with B&W. Sorry if that upsets some people. It's just my opinion. B&W should be reserved for the exceptional 1 in a thousand shot and only then to help bring out the atmosphere.

You come off the fence there and tell us what you really feel :lol:
2blue4u
23-06-2007, 22:31
You come off the fence there and tell us what you really feel :lol:

:D sorry. I don't do fences ;)
inophoto
23-06-2007, 22:38
I went with the colour. That was just what I needed.

Cheers chaps!
CT
24-06-2007, 00:07
Colour! Just crop it tight on the left. :)
Messiah Khan
24-06-2007, 09:29
Colour! Just crop it tight on the left. :)

What he said. Except i'd crop more off the right hand side. Reduce the amount of background on the right hand side by about half and it would be perfect imo.:)
tank
30-06-2007, 13:48
the colour shot for me! looks great. very well lit!
lee
03-07-2007, 09:00
Thats a lovely portrait, and would definitely have to go with the colour version.
Henry
07-07-2007, 22:49
Love the colour. Good portrait, intersting background.