Good or Bad I just don't know

[whiteflyer]

I can't decide if I like this or not. So fire away Crap or OK

I used LucisArt Whyeth filter in CS3 for the effect

http://i135.photobucket.com/albums/q142/whiteflyer/st-peters-1.jpg

[Cobra]

I love the overall effect but I am not convinced on the perspective though. I think that there maybe 2 images in there?

[CT]

Certainly not crap -far from it. Looks rather HDR I thought.

[Amp34]

Very nice, although I agree with cobra, I don't think the gravestone does anything for the shot.

[dazzajl]

I can't decide if I like this or not

Nor me.

I think perhaps I quite like the effect but not on that subject. Looks like it could be great on something quite abstract, where you won't be able to see so clearly what it's doing.

A bit like lens filters, where I always feel that if you can see where one's been used, it's over used.

[mobilevirgin]

I really like the effect. I think it works well. I'm less sure about the composition of the pic though - the cross gets in the way of the back end of the church (am I allowed to suggest a church has a back end?)

[oldgit]

Very nice, although I agree with cobra, I don't think the gravestone does anything for the shot.

:agree:

Good sky and detail in the church

[moomike]

:agree: too.
I'd up the contrast though as it's looking rather "dusty" to me :thumbs:

[focused]

I'd be very happy to have taken that shot. I think it great.