Which is better?

[Jaykay]

Hi, which version of this picture do you prefer? #1 or #2?

#1
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2234/2286448618_6f8888bf2e.jpg


#2
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2011/2286448822_e2cd424f0c.jpg


Or should I just try and process it in a completely different way?

Thanks

[PapaLazarou]

Number 1

[marky_h]

#1. Her image is all about stark colours, and the photo should reflect that.

[james_death]

Number 1

[tank]

Maybe take a little saturation out of the first one.

[Betty]

Oooh, I actually prefer the second :thumbs:

[mmcp42]

hmmm
must say "I wouldn't start from here"
not really into this grunge stuff

mebbe a head and shoulders crop of #1 might do :shrug:

[Jaykay]

Thanks for the feedback it has helped me a lot :)

[F-Stop]

I like the socks in #1, but the overall processing in #2... I'm at an impass. :)