Which pano is best?

[JumboBeef]

I shot two panos today....well, one but with two different results. Using a full 360 and 11 photos, I have two results:

http://www.zzmail.co.uk/images/ulls_panorama1.jpg

http://www.zzmail.co.uk/images/ulls_panorama2.jpg

Which one do you think is best? C+C most welcome!

[Mart61]

Gosh. Given a choice, I like no. 2 the best. However, I'm struggling to find a subject in either of them. Perhaps if I could see a larger printed shot I'd see it?

[JumboBeef]

mmmmmmmmmmmm.........

There is supposed to be a large boat in the middle of the shot (second shot, and off to the left in the first shot).

Where did that go? :thinking: :bonk:

[Mart61]

There ya go - that'd draw me in, were it there... :D

[kfridge]

second one for me...in the first, the small boats in the middle seem to be landlocked!

[Ajophotog]

Both good in different ways, damn I can't choose :lol: #2 :lol:

[Mick]

The second for sure. I dont like the fact that the action is center in #1 and the scene fizzles out to the left and right. #2 is framed much better.

Mick.

[Albedo]

Two is better framed I think!

[AndrewA123]

# 2 for me, The road in the middle is somewhat distracting and perhaps too central. I feel the boats and the road on the left of #2 helps to frame the shot better.

Both nece though :)

[JumboBeef]

Thanks for the replies.

Thinking about it, I'm not really happy with either.............onwards and upwards!

[Misty]

:thinking: Difficult choice but I prefer the 2nd

[DarknFuzzy]

Number 2 most deffinately. :)