Nikkor 17-55 2.8 or 28-70 2.8 which is better

[PsiFox]

Not after thoughts re focal length per se, just which people think is the better lens a looking to get one.

Thanks

[puddleduck]

For DX, the 17-55 is a much better lens. Sharper wide open.

If you are thinking of going full frame, the 28-70 f/2.8 AF-S is still fine, although its somewhat over-rated, and outclassed by the newer 24-70.

[dizzledazzle]

Ive only ever heard great things about the 17-55..

[fracster]

I have the 17-55 and rate it highly. Don`t know about the other as I have never had one.

AFAIK 17-55 is DX only,I think the 28-70 will work on either, so if your planning on going to FF, maybe the 28-70 would be the better option.