PDA

View Full Version : Which one?

P-E
14-07-2006, 18:56
Ok I am struggling with my processing:(

Both edited using different RAW convertor and finalised in CS2.

Which looks better ABC or D

Ahttp://i43.photobucket.com/albums/e368/IAN-UK/test-A.jpgBhttp://i43.photobucket.com/albums/e368/IAN-UK/test-B.jpg

Chttp://i43.photobucket.com/albums/e368/IAN-UK/C.jpgDhttp://i43.photobucket.com/albums/e368/IAN-UK/D.jpg
Hacker
14-07-2006, 19:18
#1 for me, the saturated colours and higher contrast add to the drama of the shot.
neonpollen
14-07-2006, 19:21
For me it's B :)
CT
14-07-2006, 19:26
I like 'em both. I like the better sense of space and distance in B as the light fades towards the distance and is more natural, but the better contrast and foreground detail in A. Sorry! :D

Now if you could combine the two? ;)

Lovely shot btw.
P-E
14-07-2006, 19:36
Thanks chaps for taking the time to comment:thumbs:

So it's a split decision so far.
Venomator
14-07-2006, 19:38
A easily P-E ... does that sway it then ... :lol:

More clarity, better contrast and just clearer all round ... imo :p
P-E
14-07-2006, 19:40
Vent your lying.......I just seen how dodgy you are:lol:
Matt
14-07-2006, 19:41
A for me

B seems to have a red colour cast blobbed in the centre.

HTH
Venomator
14-07-2006, 19:41
Vent your lying.......I just seen how dodgy you are:lol:

HeeHeeHeeHeeHeeHee ...

I can see no-one is gonna trust me no more ... right :naughty:

Better find another site where I'm not known ... :p
P-E
14-07-2006, 19:55
Right well A was processed using RSE and B using Canon's DPP.

It's no secret I have struggled with RSE but since reading Matt's tutorial things have started to improve.......until my recent outing, where RSE appeared to give a horrible shade of green in the grass in a few of my pictures.

RSE does appear to give a little more detail:thinking:

I would miss yer Ven:hug:
KenCo
14-07-2006, 20:17
A here too, just seems a little richer.
mrgubby
14-07-2006, 22:03
Right , Just to add to the mix....


A , better textures , 53% of the vote

B , more natural colours , 46% of the vote

1% lost due to Abbot Bitter

:)
nightfire
15-07-2006, 15:55
I prefer B.

On my monitor the foreground in A looks as if it's had a little too much sharpening and B has the better overall colours.
Hoodi
15-07-2006, 16:02
I prefer A to look at online, but I think B would make a better, more neutral, print.
GfK
15-07-2006, 16:03
B.

A is a little too 'sharp' for my taste.
P-E
16-07-2006, 08:07
Cheers fellas.

Looks like A is the preferred one of the two.
InaGlo
16-07-2006, 11:11
Yup... another 'A' here too!
ppp
16-07-2006, 18:33
b
Karamac
16-07-2006, 19:33
both good but I think its B for me
matty
16-07-2006, 21:08
A for me, just better
P-E
17-07-2006, 18:56
Right I have added a C

Any thoughts on that one converted using a different RAW converter.

I promise there won't be a D :D.......sorry broke my promise;) there is a D.

So ABC & D

Same RAW file converted and edited in CS2.

RSE
DPP
CAPTURE 1
BIBBLE PRO
chuckles
17-07-2006, 19:09
My money's on 'A'....the other two seem a trifle bland to me. ;)