Which is better?

wac

Messages

32

Name

Will

Edit My Images

No

• 22 Apr 2011

• #1

I have to submit one of the two photos as part of a project but I'm too close to it and can't decide which of them to submit. So which do you guys prefer on face value.

Thanks

 

N

Nikon Fan

Messages

798

Name

Barry

Edit My Images

Yes

• 22 Apr 2011

• #2

I prefer the first as it shows just a tad of detail in the dakrness.

 

leftcurl

Messages

4,085

Name

Leigh

Edit My Images

Yes

• 22 Apr 2011

• #3

i've picked mine.... the voting is very close! How are you going to decide if it's a dead heat?

 

Trig's

Messages

4,367

Name

Steve

Edit My Images

Yes

• 22 Apr 2011

• #4

The 1st just pips it for me - only as the hand in the 2nd is too blurred for me - if it wasn't then it would've been the 2nd.... But only just thou..

 

lizzy23

Messages

2,167

Name

Liz

Edit My Images

Yes

• 22 Apr 2011

• #5

the first one for me as well, just that touch of detail swings it for me

 

E

ecniv

Messages

3,723

Edit My Images

Yes

• 22 Apr 2011

• #6

Extra detail in #1

Although the blurred hand on #2 in #1 pic might work...

 

danieljamesphoto

Messages

403

Edit My Images

No

• 22 Apr 2011

• #7

ecniv said:

Although the blurred hand on #2 in #1 pic might work...

Click to expand...

Exactly why I chose it love the movement!

 

Llama

Messages

780

Name

Jack

Edit My Images

Yes

• 22 Apr 2011

• #8

can i be difficut and say i would combine them, keep the decks and hand from the firts use the body from the second

 

S

Steeps

Messages

357

Name

Dan

Edit My Images

Yes

• 22 Apr 2011

• #9

First shot due to being able to see more detail, doesn't look as flat

 

ziggy©

Messages

1,939

Name

Dini

Edit My Images

Yes

• 22 Apr 2011

• #10

#1

 

AlfyB

Messages

429

Name

Ian

Edit My Images

Yes

• 22 Apr 2011

• #11

Another vote for #1

 

Chaz Photos

Jack Elam

Messages

6,282

Name

Chaz

Edit My Images

Yes

• 22 Apr 2011

• #12

well I said #2 for the guy but like the decks more in #1 so may be combine the two. shame he is so far to the right looking out of the image....

 

OP

wac

Messages

32

Name

Will

Edit My Images

No

• 23 Apr 2011

• #13

Cheers for the feedback guys, it looks like there's a pretty clear majority here!

 

andrewc

Messages

9,819

Name

Andrew

Edit My Images

Yes

• 23 Apr 2011

• #14

Using the AV system, it is 1, followed by 2