Critique : Some clear weather at last!

niallrbroome · 05-03-2013, 11:45

been a while since its been a nice warm evening .... lets hope there are plenty more to come

all c&c welcome

1

**** by niallrbroome, on Flickr

2

**** by niallrbroome, on Flickr

3

Sunset Steps by niallrbroome, on Flickr

4

Woosh by niallrbroome, on Flickr

5

Lighthouse by niallrbroome, on Flickr

cheers
Niall

JakeT1992 · 05-03-2013, 13:35

Hi Niall,
2 & 4 are the best for me!
The first is too central, and the mass expanse of plain sky doesn't help. I'd lose it if I'm honest, even if it means losing the moon.
The third is nice, great colours and a nice scene, I wish there was something after the steps however, as the mid ground is a bit empty.
The last doesn't work for me, purely due to the angles and the use of fish eye.

niallrbroome · 05-03-2013, 13:58 **Thread Starter**

Quote:

Originally Posted by JakeT1992

Hi Niall,
2 & 4 are the best for me!
The first is too central, and the mass expanse of plain sky doesn't help. I'd lose it if I'm honest, even if it means losing the moon.
The third is nice, great colours and a nice scene, I wish there was something after the steps however, as the mid ground is a bit empty.
The last doesn't work for me, purely due to the angles and the use of fish eye.

Thanks for the comments

I see what you mean now about the third, maybe if i try a lower angle next time to cut out some of the foreground might make for a better image ... noted

fuzzyfelt30 · 05-03-2013, 15:16

I actually like the first one, except for the fact that the stone is so central.....with that in mind, I tried a little copy and paste to see what it would look like on a third and with the moon moved over a little - I hope you don't mind!

guernsey by Fuzzyfelt30, on Flickr

Big Nick · 05-03-2013, 17:13

I like the last two

Dexter247 · 05-03-2013, 17:34

I like the beach and the lighthouse shots best. Is it possible to get an angle on the standing stone that did not include the house in the background which might add to the atmosphere and add some mystery.

trueno86 · 07-03-2013, 09:34

how do u get that effect on number 4????

niallrbroome · 07-03-2013, 09:37 **Thread Starter**

Quote:

Originally Posted by trueno86

how do u get that effect on number 4????

just a longish exposure, that was shot at f22, ISO 100, 1sec shutter @ 18mm. just wait for the tide to come in and then as it rolls back out it creates the lines.

cheers all for all the comments

trueno86 · 08-03-2013, 13:53

thanx for the help, i'll try it when i get a chance. great shots

gramps · 08-03-2013, 13:57

#2 is a very nicely composed shot with some great colours and #4 a very good example of a long exposure seashore ... if only #1 didn't have the stone slap bang in the middle it would have been another stunner

PaulPNel · 08-03-2013, 14:13

Quote:

Originally Posted by gramps

#2 is a very nicely composed shot with some great colours and #4 a very good example of a long exposure seashore ... if only #1 didn't have the stone slap bang in the middle it would have been another stunner

Could possibly do some creative cropping and bring it back!

fuzzyfelt30 · 08-03-2013, 16:54

Perhaps like the version a bit higher up the page??

gramps · 08-03-2013, 16:56

Quote:

Originally Posted by PaulPNel

Could possibly do some creative cropping and bring it back!

Quote:

Originally Posted by fuzzyfelt30

Perhaps like the version a bit higher up the page??

Very true, but giving crit on the original

KelvinB · 08-03-2013, 17:26

Number 2 is the best bar far for me.

trueno86 · 09-03-2013, 01:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by niallrbroome

just a longish exposure, that was shot at f22, ISO 100, 1sec shutter @ 18mm. just wait for the tide to come in and then as it rolls back out it creates the lines.

cheers all for all the comments

thank you. did u use a nd filter also????

05-03-2013, 17:34	#6
Dexter247 Been here a while Real name : Chris Location: Grateley nr Andover Posts: 260 Camera: Pentax K-R	I like the beach and the lighthouse shots best. Is it possible to get an angle on the standing stone that did not include the house in the background which might add to the atmosphere and add some mystery. __________________ I'm OK it's all the others

08-03-2013, 13:57	#10
gramps Growing roots Location: UK Posts: 8,575 Camera: Nikon D3s & D800	#2 is a very nicely composed shot with some great colours and #4 a very good example of a long exposure seashore ... if only #1 didn't have the stone slap bang in the middle it would have been another stunner __________________ I like taking photos and I know what I like, I'm not a professional photographer. If I offer feedback on your photos it's just as I see them and because I am trying to give friendly support and help. I hope you will do the same.

05-03-2013, 11:45	#1
niallrbroome Getting Comfy Real name : Niall Location: Guernsey Posts: 189 Camera: Nikon D40 / D90	Some clear weather at last! been a while since its been a nice warm evening .... lets hope there are plenty more to come all c&c welcome 1 ** by niallrbroome, on Flickr 2 ** by niallrbroome, on Flickr 3 Sunset Steps by niallrbroome, on Flickr 4 Woosh by niallrbroome, on Flickr 5 Lighthouse by niallrbroome, on Flickr cheers Niall __________________ My Website My Flickr

05-03-2013, 13:35	#2
JakeT1992 Feet under the table Real name : Jake Location: Swindon, Wiltshire Posts: 2,727 Camera: Canon EOS 5D MkIII	Hi Niall, 2 & 4 are the best for me! The first is too central, and the mass expanse of plain sky doesn't help. I'd lose it if I'm honest, even if it means losing the moon. The third is nice, great colours and a nice scene, I wish there was something after the steps however, as the mid ground is a bit empty. The last doesn't work for me, purely due to the angles and the use of fish eye. __________________ Flickr Please like my page on Facebook! My 365 challenge 2013!!

05-03-2013, 15:16	#4
fuzzyfelt30 Getting Comfy Real name : Mike Location: North Dordogne, France Posts: 145 Camera: Pentax K5	I actually like the first one, except for the fact that the stone is so central.....with that in mind, I tried a little copy and paste to see what it would look like on a third and with the moon moved over a little - I hope you don't mind! guernsey by Fuzzyfelt30, on Flickr Last edited by fuzzyfelt30; 05-03-2013 at 15:19.

05-03-2013, 17:13	#5
Big Nick Getting Comfy Location: North Yorkshire Posts: 183 Camera: Nikon D3100	I like the last two

07-03-2013, 09:34	#7
trueno86 New here Real name : joe Posts: 31	how do u get that effect on number 4????

08-03-2013, 13:53	#9
trueno86 New here Real name : joe Posts: 31	thanx for the help, i'll try it when i get a chance. great shots

08-03-2013, 16:54	#12
fuzzyfelt30 Getting Comfy Real name : Mike Location: North Dordogne, France Posts: 145 Camera: Pentax K5	Perhaps like the version a bit higher up the page??

08-03-2013, 17:26	#14
KelvinB New here Location: Weymouth Posts: 40 Camera: Nikon D5100	Number 2 is the best bar far for me.