Lovely Pair, for me difficult to seperate the two as i like them both. Fantastic textures with sand, rock and weed. I also like the misty sea and scudding cloud (But watch out for the shutter speed police). Its a really cracking sharp forground focus and i love the way the light has picked out the lighthouse on the horizon very nice, and great composition IMHO. Its not often that i see a B&W that equals a Colour or vice versa but this is it. Although i do think that on the colour version the island and light house are picked out much better as is the little puddles in the mid foreground.
Lovely Work, Well Done!