Greenfinch

[Joeturner11]

Not really sure what I think about this to be honest, personally feel its too small in the frame the bird is but like the perch and background, any thoughts on this?

Can't make up my mind if its one for the webby, keep or bin...

 

[Solo man]

It's a pleasing image for sure.... but I'm also not sure about it being small in the frame, and I think a crop would spoil it.

 

[eccles]

I don't think it's a greenfinch. Female siskin maybe?

 

[gramps]

Looks like a young Greenfinch to me - a pleasing image Joe, I don't think all bird images have to be 'in your face', I would keep it

 

[Jannyfox]

I don't think all bird images have to be 'in your face', I would keep it

 

[Joeturner11]

Thanks for the comments everyone Will add to to the keep list

 

[BillN_33]

Joe, you need to post a bigger crop for comparison, maybe two thirds the size - as is I'm not convinced at all

 

[twitcher]

Just a run of the mill image of a Greenfinch, nice but you need to get a lot closer to get some detail in the bird.

Nige.

 

[Neil B]

Sorry Joe but it's a bin it from me.

 

[Joeturner11]

Cheers guys, Think I agree for the bin, Cheers Neil & Nigel for your blunt critique just the answers I was looking for, Thanks