Re-edit which do you prefer?

[chrisc]

Ive been playing around with a few old pictures and came across one i had forgot about from the end of last year so i done a quick re-edit and i feel it improves it. What does everyone else think?

Original

DSC_2909 by jctcanavan, on Flickr

Re-edit

DSC_2909-2 by jctcanavan, on Flickr

 

[Peter B]

I prefer the second shot because it benefits from higher contrast.

 

[shannensdaddy]

I like the colours in the first shot ..looks like the lumier festival ...

 

[chrisc]

Yeah it was the lumier festival

 

[propaintballa]

I prefer the original

 

[HopefulM]

first shot

 

[sep9001]

First one as well.

 

[sbowler579]

First one as well.

 

[wchadders]

First one for me also.....

 

[dinners]

Number 2

 

[turbominij]

i prefer the second one because of the contrast and extra detail

 

[SFTPhotography]

Second. The toning gives it bags more atmosphere

 

[69Bonni]

I'm with Number 2 here for the same reasons above!

 

[canon_togger]

The second for me also

 

[chrisc]

Thanks for the comments I also prefer the 2nd shot

 

[shannensdaddy]

Yeah it was the lumier festival

Where was this one ?, we had it last year as part of the city of culture Derry 2013 ..It was amazing ..

 

[chrisc]

Where was this one ?, we had it last year as part of the city of culture Derry 2013 ..It was amazing ..

That's the old church in St. Columb's Park