with or without?

Joe©

Joe©

Messages
360
Name
Joe Kelly
Edit My Images
Yes
the boat in the background - i feel without but still it adds something for me


quite undecided, please comments?

DSCF0047.jpg



DSCF0047healed.jpg
 
Lasagne said:
I'd say without as well. What processing have you done on this ? It has a kind of painting effect - is it HDR ? (or pseudo HDR before anyone pipes up)

Also - whereabouts in Bolton is it ? :)
Click to expand...


Post processing is tweaks in saturation

it has the look due to water on the glass of the housing unit - i am in water as i was snorkelling and doing some underwater photography


erm its in egypt red sea near bolton 3 continents away lol
 
i think without or at least remove the orange and blue from the mast. wouldnt catch the eye quite so much then. great shot all the same.
 
I think it’s a more interesting shot with it in. I would be more worried about the edge of the sale sticking out of his chest.
 
I really like this picture, and it has to be without the boat for me :)

But if you were to leave it in I would desaturate it as it does draw your eye to it and away from the main action/focal point. That's just my opinion anyway.
 
I'd say without as well... I like the focus being on the surfer and the boat in the background is very bright so sort of takes away from the surfer :)

It's lovely *** :)
 
I'd say without, for me it definitely detracts from the main subject. But go with whatever you like more, it's your photo!

Chris
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top