Colour or BW

[troutfisher]

Took these on my phone when I was out for a walk the other day. The light was rubbish but the mist added a bit of interest.
Personally I prefer the BW versions but what do others think?

and In colour

 

[THIRTYFIVEMILL]

Prefer the colour myself but would be good with a little "clean up" in places to remove a few distractions.

 

[Ploddles]

IMO, you have lost a lot of detail in your conversion. There should be a better conversion in there somewhere - too much black, too much white and not enough grey as presented.

 

[THIRTYFIVEMILL]

Something like this is what I mean:

 

[jondc]

Yes, the colour is the better of the two IMHO.

 

[ancient_mariner]

Colour for me with Dunc's cleanup, but the phone lacks dynamic range and has blown the sky.