Lots to see in the Gate image, but the bird on the pole is nice and simple. All very good.
Pete
Wow that is a huge puddle! I often use my walking poles to help me get round puddles, but I'd have to pole vault around that one!
All on theme. I like the golden light in the gate, but the pole is also a strong image.
Best one in the main thread Jim, very moody and a nice low key shot I'd say.
I think you chose the right one - I like it.
#1 is the best IMO Jim, and I'd say it fits right in on both accounts.
Yes it’s #1 for me too, very brooding and atmospheric, perfect for the theme.
Cheers for the comments, I see what you meanRough
They're all pretty good looking to me. The low-key works in the most part. I'd maybe just lighten the breakwater.
Yep No.. 1 for me too. Nice moody scene.
A bit too over-processed for my liking. The triangle thing has a halo around it. (which often happens to me when I get trigger happy with the Clarity slider) Something halfway between the original and the edit would work better in my humble opinion.
It looks like a really aggressive ocean. And for me, it doesn't need the barrier thing in it. Images don't always need foreground interest or leading lines if they don't add to the photo. I think I prefer image 3 out of all of them because the barrier literally "points" to the triangle thing which then becomes the focus of the image. It's not "rough" in my mind though like #2 could be if it was #1 dialled down by 50%.
I like it personally - moody, gritty and works for low key for me.
I like the colour version the neutral colour tones are great the first one is a little over processed I feel.
I like the pov and perspective on #1 but like others have said it looks a little over processed / contrasty. It looks a little wonky to me but could be the hills on the right hand side throwing out my eyesight. My horizons are always on the wonk so don't trust my judgement
It's an optical illusion. If you stare at the brown top of the bird's head for a short time then stare at his eye, the top of his head seems to move. Of course I could be having a stroke
That's a very colourful shot Jim, very nice.
That's a beautifully detailed shot that really shows the lovely colours. I have a pheasant that will feed from my hand in my garden. I can vouch for the fact that his beak is not very smooth
Lovely detailed shot but yeah - the mighty horn of shoe.
Very detailed and nicely composed. It might be a shoehorn but I'm struggling with this theme so I say that's ok