Critique Old Rusty Bum-Angel of the North

I think the black and white image is the best, maybe because it also doesn't have any haloing and chromatic aberration like the other two do. Which gives me the impression that in extract more detail out of the rusty bum angel of the north, that you've pushed the shadows too far to the right and the highlights too far to the left? The CA on the third one, especially along the ground is very bad. I know you can reduce CA in PP, but if you push it too much it is very time consuming to remove.
 
Black and white image works really well, but lose the bush on the bottom right.
 
I just like to try different edits whilst learning. Its good to get differing opinions.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top