Opinions, Please!

Messages
2,777
Name
Drake
Edit My Images
Yes
New versions posted further down...


Here are two versions...from slightly different perspectives. I'm very interested in your opinions on which of the two is better, especially regarding composition as opposed to the duotoning, which is not equivalent between the two. So, really...does the corner of a second building in version 1 add to the photo? Or, is the flag in version 2 a more important element? Or...whatever your thoughts might be.

Version 1:


Hancock Tower Plus Web by hunter20ga, on Flickr


Version 2:


Hancock Tower in the Fog by hunter20ga, on Flickr
 
Last edited:
Much prefer the second one. Stronger lead in lines and sense of scale, maybe due to the flags. Better compositition, more of a sense of awe as it dissapears into the fog. Really like it, no contest really. (y)
 
Much prefer the second one. Stronger lead in lines and sense of scale, maybe due to the flags. Better compositition, more of a sense of awe as it dissapears into the fog. Really like it, no contest really. (y)

I think I agree with this...but on the otherhand I might like #1 more if the building on the rhs was cloned out:thinking:
 
I too wouild like to see No1 without the rh building - both nice shots though

Les (y)
 
Back
Top