Beginner Pink Floyd "Animals"

[Rudlin]

Hello,
This is my humble attempt to replicate "Animals" album cover picture. I now know that I got angle 180 degrees wrong, shame but aside from that I need your opinion on which picture would fit best to original CD.

#1 Original image + PP:

Battersea power station by Rudlin, on Flickr

#2 Original image + PP + vignetting + grain


Battersea power station by Rudlin, on Flickr

#3 Original image in B&W + vignetting + grain


Battersea power station by Rudlin, on Flickr

Thank you.

 

[robinchun]

Great music though, still prefer 'Wish You Were Here'

Robin

 

[Dexter247]

Number one works for me, all you need is a flying pig.