Critique South Stack

iansimpson888

iansimpson888

Messages
386
Edit My Images
Yes
Looking for a little feedback if possible on these shots from South Stack in Angelsey.
Carried out some initial PP on the images in a few styles (one or two of the shots had the PP pasted from another shot). So any PP thoughts are welcome too.
Normally I'm pretty decisive over these things, maybe I need to put them in a box and forget about them for a few months....

1.a.

Untitled by Ian Simpson, on Flickr

1.b.

Untitled by Ian Simpson, on Flickr

1.c.

Untitled by Ian Simpson, on Flickr

1.d.

Untitled by Ian Simpson, on Flickr

1.e.

Untitled by Ian Simpson, on Flickr

2.

Untitled by Ian Simpson, on Flickr

3.

Untitled by Ian Simpson, on Flickr

4.

Untitled by Ian Simpson, on Flickr

Thanks.......
 
If it matters, I use Lightroom but I do have access to Photoshop (even though I've never used it)
 
Hi Ian,
I think 1e is the best of that series as the blown sun in the other shots really spoils them for me. Personally I would of looked at angles where you didn't have the sun in shot or waited a little longer so it wasn't so strong.

3 is spoilt by the sky imo, looks really noisy and overworked, 4 is pleasant enough but not the best light.
 
Neil Burnell said:
Hi Ian,
I think 1e is the best of that series as the blown sun in the other shots really spoils them for me. Personally I would of looked at angles where you didn't have the sun in shot or waited a little longer so it wasn't so strong.

3 is spoilt by the sky imo, looks really noisy and overworked, 4 is pleasant enough but not the best light.
Click to expand...

Haha, now you mention the sky in 3 it really does stand out!! Think I may need to dial that back a little!!!
 
Nice set of images Ian, #1e, would probably be my fav' but you were certainly up against some hard to deal with light. I also like #3 (B&W) shot for the good contrasty presentation but do feel you've over PPd it a little.(y)

George.
 
G.K.Jnr. said:
Nice set of images Ian, #1e, would probably be my fav' but you were certainly up against some hard to deal with light. I also like #3 (B&W) shot for the good contrasty presentation but do feel you've over PPd it a little.(y)

George.
Click to expand...

Yeah, me too now i look at it a few weeks later, think i'll revisit the image!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top