I'm personally not a fan of #2, I don't feel its a very strong composition and the picture looks a bit flat, however. I do like the first one a lot! I personally love milky looking water so its right up my street. The only thing I will point out is that there some odd blues in the water on the left handside of the image, and a bit on the bottom. Looks a bit out of place, not sure if its a case of pushing the saturation to far there or not