I quite like these Tori, normally I am not a fan of close cropping but it deffinitely works in this case, I think because you have used a fairly shallow depth of field by using f/5 it seems to have concentrated the picture on the face even more.
I would like to make a couple of suggestions, unlike the bird pics you did in poor light, where you needed to get the shutter speed up, the same problem wasnt present here. You could have reduced the ISO to probably 200, even 100, which would have lessened the BG noise, using flash you shouldnt have to change the other settings you have used.
Make sure you are focussing directly on the eye, it looks like you might have been on the fur just in front of it. Lastly, if you apply some sharpening (USM) in Elements, it will bring the pictures much more to life.
You have every right to be happier with these, they are good work and well done, improvements already
A quick sharpen. If you want this removed, please say so, its no problem.