same photo, 2 styles

[fontmoss]

I'm not sure which treatment i prefer, both have merits but i dont know if the colour version just has a bit more snap to it?

 

[Toothie]

i prefer the tones in the fisrt one

 

[Merovingian]

i prefer the tones in the fisrt one

 

[jimjam]

1st one for me

 

[crazylady]

me too!!!

 

[psenior1]

I prefer the first, I think because the skin tone between the face and arms is so different in the second. Might look good in a low contrast B&W too...

 

[Garry79]

I actually prefer the second. It looks like a classic painting.

 

[Crocky]

I prefer the first.

 

[fontmoss]

cheers folks, seems like garry and i are in the minority then!

 

[Garry79]

cheers folks, seems like garry and i are in the minority then!

It's cool mate, we know who are right.

 

[V8burble]

I'll join the minority! #2 for me (although it is just a 'touch' over green)

 

[ps2user]

I prefer picture No1 - I find that the vibrant colours from the compact mirror she is holding being more of the focal point instead of the woman.

 

[Button]

No1

I really like no 2 except for the mirror in her hand it just stands out too much and I find my eye been drawn to that.