Help with understanding issue relating to RAW/JPEG files

Messages
1
Name
Tom Wooding
Edit My Images
Yes
Hello everyone, new user here- glad to be a part of the community

I have noticed that my RAW images imported into Lightroom (cloud based) are cropped in and I lose a small amount from every side, compared to when opened and viewed in Windows File Explorer. When I shoot JPEG+RAW and compare the images in File Explorer the JPEGs are noticeably cropped- it’s probably only a small percentage but when you A/B them you can clearly see it. When the RAW file is then uploaded to Lightroom it’s receiving the image with the appearance of the JPEG and when you open crop there is no more image to make it bigger.

This happens for both of my cameras- a Panasonic GX80, and a Nikon D200.
To clarify- neither cameras have lens correction in camera. In fact my old DSLR doesn’t even have that capability I believe, and I’ve searched the menu.

I also have no image correction settings on in Lightroom, although even if I did this wouldn’t explain what’s happening with the files outside of Lightroom!
I’m also shooting the cameras at their native aspect ratio.

Extra piece of information I’m not sure is relevant: When I open the RAW file in File Explorer it loads the image in exactly like how it is in Lightroom (cropped) and then almost ‘pulls back’ and reveals the extra information on each side. It’s like when this file is then put into Lightroom it’s receiving the non whole version.

I’ve spent many hours searching online for possible explanations and nothing fits. This is obviously very upsetting because I have now realised that all my images in Lightroom are incomplete/cropped in.

I’d very much appreciate some help with this
Thank you,
Tom
 
Unless you have installed the "windows raw image extension" you will be viewing the embedded Jpeg File when using file explorer.

That extension is free from microsoft.
 
The import function in lightroom is maybe doing something to your images by default. I’d start by looking there.

A five minute google though suggests that if no cropping or lens correction is being done, then it could simply be that Windows explorer is giving you out of spec pixels, check the image size (in pixels) in LR and compare to the published specs for your cameras.
 
Last edited:
The import function in lightroom is maybe doing something to your images by default. I’d start by looking there.

A five minute google though suggests that if no cropping or lens correction is being done, then it could simply be that Windows explorer is giving you out of spec pixels, check the image size (in pixels) in LR and compare to the published specs for your cameras.
It could well be lens correction, I find that the RAW files from both my Fujifilm cameras have lens correction applied automatically by LR and ACR where as it had to be manually applied to Canon 2CR and 3CR files.

It may be something in my Lightroom and Photoshop settings but it is consistent across both Adobe products.

To add: Even when re editing old Canon files I have to manually apply lens correction so it is not something I have recently changed.

Further thought: If you can save RAW and Jpeg at the same time in camera it would be interesting to compare both to how windows is treating the images.
 
Lens correction can be enabled automatically and need not being obvious.
 
Back
Top