Help me decide please ....

Messages
103
Edit My Images
No
Thinking of finally joining the mirrorless club and replacing my aging (but excellent) Canon 5D with either a Canon R6 Mark III or an R8 Mark II .......... Please help me decide.

Do I really need the extra pixels (32 against 24.2)? The R8 is a bit smaller and lighter which would be nice for my aging body to cope with and also work better for travel situations. The R6 is a bit more expensive, but affordable.

Which would you choose? I own a range of Canon EF fit lenses so would need an adaptor, or trade them for RF fit which I would be OK with. Help! All advice and opinions welcome. Thanks you.
 
Either is going to be a massive step up. I went 6D to R6 mk1.

I'd really go R6 3, R8 2 is another R6 2 rebody, and it (the R6 3) just seems to be the best all rounder at the moment.

Primary gains personally would be the bonus cropping, the better EVF, dual card support, 1/8000 mech shutter speed (vs 1/4000 on the R8), double the battery life, control dial on the back.

Better FPS, proper HDMI etc are nice to haves for me but still for the price difference. I think the marginal weight gain of the R6 still puts it lighter than the 5D even if you factor in the EF adapter.
 
I own a range of Canon EF fit lenses so would need an adaptor, or trade them for RF fit which I would be OK with.

If you're going to use the EF lenses with a converter then those older lenses probably aren't up to delivering the extra resolution you'd want for a 32MPx sensor.

the better EVF, dual card support, 1/8000 mech shutter speed (vs 1/4000 on the R8), double the battery life

These are real-world gains in performance and worth having.
 
If not for your existing lenses I'd say go for Sony for the smaller package and larger range of both Sony and 3rd party lenses. Other than that, I think 33mp offers advantages over 24mp if the cost is reasonable. Good luck choosing.
 
go down the micro four thirds route. Smaller cameras lighter lenses , that is whatIi did and bought the panason G9 and then added the G9ii. Then you have dual IS camera +lens IS. best move I ever made. any MFT lens makefits any MFT camera make, you now have the widest of choices possible G9ii not only dual sd cards but also SSD drive
 
Last edited:
The R6iii for me, the reduced size and weight of the R8ii will disappear once you attach the EF converter and a decent lens.

That said, as Toni said, the extra resolution might test some older lenses. Personally I’m a fan of the lower res FF cameras, I don’t need the resolution, and the low light performance is like magic.
 
Thank you all for your thoughts.

@ancient_mariner I hadn't considered the lens resolution issue. Some of my collection are getting a bit old now, so maybe need to talk to my in house banker and see if we can't run to some newer RF fit ones! :)

@woof woof and @realspeed I hadn't considered other brands, having been a Canon disciple for decades, but certainly worth a look before I spend the money.

Still thinking, but veering towards the R6 III.

Thank you all again.

....... ( ...... goes off to check bank balance .......... ) ......
 
R6 mk3 recommendation from me, have had mine since July and my other cameras have seen almost zero use since (5Dmk4, R7 and 1Dmk4) and unless I really need 2 cameras on the go at once I think it will probably stay that way

Might be useful to give a bit of info about what you like to photograph as there are many features of the R6 mk3 which are fantastic but would be a total waste if you only shoot landscapes for instance.

I have used my R6mk3 with several of my older EF "L" lenses and they are perfectly OK, if they were not so good on my 5dmk4 they are still not so good on my R6mk3 and visa versa. The older lenses size does make a bit of a mockery of the smaller form factor of the mirrorless bodies but I am not about to replace all my EF "L" glass.

And if you do decide to raid your piggy bank it will still have some money left if you get it from Panamoz- other retail options are available :-)

HTH

David

AND you can borrow one for free from https://www.trythekit.com over a weekend - highly recommended.
 
Last edited:
Thank you so much for your insights @Willid1 ... I'm very much a "bit of everything" type photographer and don't specialise in any one thing. I shoot a bit of lots of things, some landscapes, but also sport (mostly equestrian sport as that's my main interest), do a few horse portraits now and then as well, carry my camera when I'm out with my dog on long walks through woods and fields locally - so shoot anything which takes my eye, odd bits of still life, I like to travel and shoot street scenes/landmarks etc or people I meet when I'm out and about. So anything I see which I think deserves a picture, I shoot with varying degrees of success!

Never heard of trying the kit before I buy: that's a great idea. I'll follow that up. Thank you again.
 
The R6iii for me, the reduced size and weight of the R8ii will disappear once you attach the EF converter and a decent lens.

That said, as Toni said, the extra resolution might test some older lenses. Personally I’m a fan of the lower res FF cameras, I don’t need the resolution, and the low light performance is like magic.
The thing is too sticking Canon and adaptor gets you going and can refine weaker lenses with RF replacements later.

Also I’d add look at an R6-2, still available via a few channels, prob cheaper than an R8 2, (edit, yep see Cotswold camera for eg the R6 2 is £50 cheaper than an R8 2) basically same camera but without the R8 crippling.

When I bought the R6 the R6 mk2 was out, but the budget was R6 mk1 or the crippled R8 mk1, and my same reasons above stand today. Brought older L glass along which still use, but I’ve updated the old EF 35mm f2 to a RF 35mm f1.8 which is my day to day lens now.
 
Last edited:
Thank you all for your thoughts.

@ancient_mariner I hadn't considered the lens resolution issue. Some of my collection are getting a bit old now, so maybe need to talk to my in house banker and see if we can't run to some newer RF fit ones! :)

@woof woof and @realspeed I hadn't considered other brands, having been a Canon disciple for decades, but certainly worth a look before I spend the money.

Still thinking, but veering towards the R6 III.

Thank you all again.

....... ( ...... goes off to check bank balance .......... ) ......
I was a dedicated Nikon owner for more years than i care to remember .From the D70s right through to the D810 version. Weight was the deciding reason for the change and it was like coming out of the dark ages . At my age of 81 years I can still handhold a Panasonic 100-400mm (200-800 mm in FF terms) still due to the truely amazing two IS one in camera and the other in the lens.
I went into a camera shop and did a P/X which covered the cost of the change on camera makes.
 
Last edited:
thing is too sticking Canon and adaptor gets you going and can refine weaker lenses with RF replacements later.
Yeah when I bought my R6 I also bought the RF50mm, and used everything else with the adaptor.
The only EF lenses I have now are an old Tamron UWA and the 135 f2L. I rarely shoot the wide angle, but the 135 is one of my most loved lenses. I just couldn’t justify the rf replacement.

In fact I’ve just had a bit of a lens clearout which included 3 almost never used RF lenses, the 16 2.8, 50 1.8 and 85 f2
 
I hadn't considered other brands, having been a Canon disciple for decades, but certainly worth a look before I spend the money

I wanted to be helpful because you weren't asking about other brands, but if you were to look at changing systems completely then I'd probably recommend the Sony system as having a good combination of performance, lower weight, more lens options and the ability to use EF mount lenses with the Sigma MC11 adapter. I've been a Sony user for a long time and Minolta before that.

At this point I'd recommended looking at systems overall, rather than just buying back into the same brand. You might well still prefer Canon, but at least you will have a better set of reasons for choosing them.
 
What lens do you use the most with the current setup?

Assuming that's to me? Sony GM 50 f1.2 followed by G 24-105. Other faves include Samyang 85 f1.4, old A mount Tamron 90 macro and Sigma 12-24 on an adapter. I've recently been using a Sigma 35 f1.2 ART in FE mount that renders well but weighs over 1kg.
 
Yeah when I bought my R6 I also bought the RF50mm, and used everything else with the adaptor.
The only EF lenses I have now are an old Tamron UWA and the 135 f2L. I rarely shoot the wide angle, but the 135 is one of my most loved lenses. I just couldn’t justify the rf replacement.

In fact I’ve just had a bit of a lens clearout which included 3 almost never used RF lenses, the 16 2.8, 50 1.8 and 85 f2
Digressing. Yeah I’ve been through about 3x Canon 50mm f1.8 plus a 50mm f2.5 macro and about the only one I shouldn’t have sold is ye olde 50mm f2.5 macro as it turns out slow and noisy it was, it’s still really really nice. I’ve sold the mk2s but I “accidentally” picked up a mk1 when wex listed it for £40 and they were still fetching £160 and I can’t bring myself to flog it because it owes me nothing really.

Also had a 135 f2 through the business and that’s a lens I should have slipped into the personal bag.

I do also keep contemplating the 85mm f2 but then I keep contemplating what would it do the 100mm USM f2.8 macro doesn’t that I’ve already got
 
I do also keep contemplating the 85mm f2 but then I keep contemplating what would it do the 100mm USM f2.8 macro doesn’t that I’ve already got
I used the EF85 loads, but it took me too long to realise that was when I shot crop. I bought the RF85 to replace both the EF85 and my 90 macro, but honestly, I’d rarely used the 90 either, so the 85 sat unused for a few years before I realised it was never gonna get used.

The 100mm macro is probably a better lens, I’d stick with it.
 
Yeah I’ve been through about 3x Canon 50mm f1.8
The STM was the best of the 50mm 1.8’s, and IMO better than the 1.4 too, and the RF version is as good. And my personal view is that the EF converter makes anything less than 100mm too big for what it is.
 
@Jonnybrad2001 I currently have a few EF lenses .... a 50mm, an 85mm, a 24-105, a 100 macro and a 70-300 (which is very heavy!).

Thinking of stretching to get a couple of RF lenses - the 18-150 (or the 24-105?) and possibly the 55-210. Would also like to get a 50mm and possibly the 100-400. I wouldn't use anything longer or wider so that feels about right just at the moment. I need to consider carrying the whole set up about. We have Christmas coming up and my birthday in January :) Let's see what happens.
 
@Jonnybrad2001 I currently have a few EF lenses .... a 50mm, an 85mm, a 24-105, a 100 macro and a 70-300 (which is very heavy!).

Thinking of stretching to get a couple of RF lenses - the 18-150 (or the 24-105?) and possibly the 55-210. Would also like to get a 50mm and possibly the 100-400. I wouldn't use anything longer or wider so that feels about right just at the moment. I need to consider carrying the whole set up about. We have Christmas coming up and my birthday in January :) Let's see what happens.
The 18-150 & 55-210 are both RF-S lenses, unlike on EF they will mount on full frame, but you're instantly chucking away a massive amount of MP, so better to stick with full RF lenses.

Is the 24-105 the old F4L? That'll probably still be alright on the R6, as is the 100mm Macro. Which 70-300 do you have? There's a heavy white L, and the black 70-300 IS USM, which on the grand scheme of things in that zoom range wasn't horrendous in weight.
 
@Jonnybrad2001 - thank you for your guidance. My 70-300 is the heavy white one. I have used it a lot on my old 5D III for sports work and it's been a very good work horse.

Looking at the list of available RF glass for the new R6 III, I'm thinking a 50mm as an everyday carry about, the 24-105 F4 and the 100-400 would cover all the bases, allow me to do what I want to do, not blow my budget by too much and reduce the weight! I might get an adaptor as well at some point, just to see how the old ones work on the new body, but I will probably still use the 5D for my sports work (I do event photography for a local riding club, amongst other things). As far as my weight carrying ability is concerned - I'm a 72 year old woman in decent shape, but lugging too much weight about gives me a back ache and takes a lot of joy out of the whole process. Hey ho - the joys of aging!!

Thank you again: I appreciate your insights.
 
@Jonnybrad2001 - thank you for your guidance. My 70-300 is the heavy white one. I have used it a lot on my old 5D III for sports work and it's been a very good work horse.

Looking at the list of available RF glass for the new R6 III, I'm thinking a 50mm as an everyday carry about, the 24-105 F4 and the 100-400 would cover all the bases, allow me to do what I want to do, not blow my budget by too much and reduce the weight! I might get an adaptor as well at some point, just to see how the old ones work on the new body, but I will probably still use the 5D for my sports work (I do event photography for a local riding club, amongst other things). As far as my weight carrying ability is concerned - I'm a 72 year old woman in decent shape, but lugging too much weight about gives me a back ache and takes a lot of joy out of the whole process. Hey ho - the joys of aging!!

Thank you again: I appreciate your insights.

I'd definitely start with the RF-EF adapter, it'll let you try the old lenses on it and see where the strengths/weaknesses are, and where you really fancy upgrading.

I've got the mk1 24-105 F4L and the old 100mm USM (non L) macro and they're not the ones shouting "I need upgrading", yes the newer versions add pixel peeping sharpness (I've not checked weight savings), but the results aren't shouting for those upgrades. The R6 also has the benefit of making my old non IS macro lens have image stabilisation too (same applies for the old 50mm F1.8 etc, I use that so rarely personally I wouldn't upgrade that).

I ran all my EF lenses for a good 6 months and I've picked up a few bits since where RF lenses add a proper upgrade.

I've swapped my (1990) 35mm F2 for the RF 35mm F1.8 as it added faster focusing, 1:2 macro, IS, so that's my general light weight walk about. I've put a 16mm F2.8 in the bag because it weighs b****r all and cost relatively speaking b****r all too. It's miles away from perfect, but with it being light/cheap I can live with that.

The 70-200 F4L has been replaced by the 100-400 F5.6-8, it adds range without adding weight, again non L it isn't going to be the very sharpest thing you can buy, but I've been very happy with it. Its 600-700g, so half the weight of the EF 100-400L or the EF 70-300L, quick focus, and small & black, so it isn't shouty when you're just wandering. I kept the 70-200 for two years but it never left the house again. Someone got me to sell their 70-300 and any temptations to swap the 100-400 for the 70-300 were dispelled after carrying it around Bempton for the day, and realising it added b****r all to the setup except weight. I preferred the results from the RF100-400.

Longer term I wouldn't mind the 200-800 F6-9 but that's big/heavy (over 2KG)/not discreet but adds masses of reach. Also I wouldn't mind swapping the 24-105 for the 28-70 F2.8 (non L)
 
Back
Top