Shocking state of affairs

Messages
4,416
Name
Wayne
Edit My Images
No
I added my carefully regulated developer at 20.4 degrees and found that immediately after adding it to the patterson type tank the temperature plummeted to 18..5 degrees, I never thought to measure the temperature shock before.

How are you overcoming this ?
 
I added my carefully regulated developer at 20.4 degrees and found that immediately after adding it to the patterson type tank the temperature plummeted to 18..5 degrees, I never thought to measure the temperature shock before.

How are you overcoming this ?

Put all your equipment in an environment around the right temperature for an hour before you start. If that's not practical, rinse the tank through with water a couple of degrees above the temperature you want to work at just before starting.
 
If Santa has deep pockets then one of those could solve the problem entirely. It automatically adjusts the times to suit temperature variations on the fly.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6XKn-hWLNYA


 
Wow, I enjoyed the vid

Not so much the second, I suppose that is cheap though for what it does and would soon pay for itself if you shoot colour film.

I don't think that it would be cost effective in my case though, I am too tight.

Thanks for sharing though, it is nice to see the innovative solutions that are actually out there. (y)
 
If Santa has deep pockets then one of those could solve the problem entirely. It automatically adjusts the times to suit temperature variations on the fly.

This won't really fix the problem sadly, because for C41 development, processing time modulation can't fix issues introduced by temperature swings (e.i. colour crossovers)

The only way to get perfect development is to stick as closely as possible to those 38 Celsius for the entire duration of the 3'15'' dev run, unfortunately.
 
Last edited:
I added my carefully regulated developer at 20.4 degrees and found that immediately after adding it to the patterson type tank the temperature plummeted to 18..5 degrees, I never thought to measure the temperature shock before.

How are you overcoming this ?

Here' a good reddit post on the matter

Lab Quality C-41 for Home Developers [your all-in-one dev bible]

Pay particular attention to the following two sections from the above:

STABILIZE YOUR TEMPS [understanding water baths and heat loss]

This causes way more problems than people realize. If your water bath is exactly 100°F, then 100°F is the absolute hottest your chemistry could ever theoretically become. Which isn’t accounting for all of the heat you’re simultaneously losing to the bottle, room air, tank, thermometer, handling, etc. In the real world, a 100°F bath means your chemistry will approach 100°F but probably never actually stabilize there.

Set your bath to around 102ºF and your chems will stabilize at 100ºF.

The other part people miss is that heat transfer is driven by the temperature gradient. If your developer is 70°F and your bath is 102°F, there’s a 32-degree delta between them, so heat transfers very quickly. Once the developer reaches 99°F, there’s only a 3-degree delta. As the two temperatures approach equilibrium, the rate of heat transfer slows dramatically, which means the last degree or two can take 25–30 minutes depending on your bottle, chemistry volume, circulation, and setup.

So either give your chemistry a long time to fully stabilize or use a calibrated digital thermometer and measure the actual developer. Don’t trust the number on the sous vide and assume the chemistry matches it. I want the developer held within about a 0.4°F/0.2C delta of target temperature.

Once you finally get everything to temperature, the goal is to stay at temperature. And that brings us to probably the most controversial step in home C-41:

THE INFAMOUS PRE-SOAK [I know everyone argues about this]

In a proper lab process, you generally do not want a pre-soak at all because the water itself introduces another set of variables before development begins. It changes the condition of the emulsion, affects swelling and chemical uptake, and can alter density and diffusion behavior. Different emulsions also react differently. In my experience, Ultramax and Portra 400 are noticeably more sensitive to an extended pre-soak than films like Kodacolor or Gold.

So why use one at home? Because the thermal situation is completely different. In dip-and-dunk processing, you can put a whole load of room-temperature rolls into a giant tank containing several hundred gallons of hot chemistry, and they barely make a dent in the temperature. At home, you may have a room-temperature tank, reels, center column, lid, and multiple rolls of film, and then pour only 500–1000mL of developer into all that cold material. That can absolutely crash the temperature of your developer. It’s all about thermal mass.

In a home-dev situation, the temperature stability gained from a very short pre-soak outweighs the negatives introduced by the pre-soak itself. The sweet spot is roughly 30–45 seconds. Go shorter, and whether you actually get the tank, reels, and film up to temperature becomes hit-or-miss. Go longer, and you start introducing more of the issues that make pre-soaking undesirable in the first place.
 
 
Last edited:
I pre-soak with water from the same source as the developer for some time. Black and white is really not that sensitive, 2 degrees is not worth worrying about for home gamers like us.

If it's colour, which is actually temperature sensitive, use a Sous Vide heater and keep the chems and film tank in a water bath for an hour to equalise. No need for expensive dev tools, you can even use the sous vide for a footbath!
 
I have never really monitored the temperature of my chemicals when developing B&W. I let them sit and reach room temperature which (assuming it's not a heatwave or really cold) is usually around 20 degrees.
 
Back
Top