40D, Speedlite 420EX and Yongnuo RF602

Messages
199
Name
Beau
Edit My Images
Yes
Evening all.

I've just bought a Yongnuo RF602 and a couple of receivers. I'm trying to get high speed flash working with a 420EX Speedlite.

Both units are working but with fairly long downtime between shots (it works fine if straight on the camera) The flash is in highspeed mode and when I try to change the settings on the camera I get "This menu cannot be displayed. Incompatible flash or flash's power is turned off"

Am I trying to do something which isn't possible?

Any help appreciated! :)
 
Evening all.

I've just bought a Yongnuo RF602 and a couple of receivers. I'm trying to get high speed flash working with a 420EX Speedlite.

Both units are working but with fairly long downtime between shots (it works fine if straight on the camera) The flash is in highspeed mode and when I try to change the settings on the camera I get "This menu cannot be displayed. Incompatible flash or flash's power is turned off"

Am I trying to do something which isn't possible?

Any help appreciated! :)

I can't do it either with the RF-602, 580EX and 40D. I think what happens is that while the flash is set for HSS, since it doesn't get the signal to fire in that mode from the RF-602 it only gives a normal flash.

The gun fires and you naturally assume that it's giving a HSS flash because that's what's been set, but it isn't and when the shutter speed is high, eg 1/2000sec, you get nothing in the picture - the regular flash has been and gone before the shutter opens.

Using the RF-602, if you slow the shutter speed down to 1/400sec say, you will get half an image which proves what's actually going on. If you do the same thing with the flash on camera but with HSS mode off, you will get an identical image, which shows that the same thing is happening with the RF-602 even though the flash is set with HSS on. Hope that makes sense!

What's happening I think is that the HSS flash code is not given through the central firing pin, but via the other hot shoe contacts. While the RF-602 appears to have a full set of contracts on the foot/shoe, in fact the only ones that work are the normal mode firing signal, and the wake-up signal to prime the flash with first press on the shutter release.

The long recycle time is normal with HSS because it works the flash very hard and it's basically flat out most of the time.
 
I can't do it either with the RF-602, 580EX and 40D. I think what happens is that while the flash is set for HSS, since it doesn't get the signal to fire in that mode from the RF-602 it only gives a normal flash.

The gun fires and you naturally assume that it's giving a HSS flash because that's what's been set, but it isn't and when the shutter speed is high, eg 1/2000sec, you get nothing in the picture - the regular flash has been and gone before the shutter opens.

Using the RF-602, if you slow the shutter speed down to 1/400sec say, you will get half an image which proves what's actually going on. If you do the same thing with the flash on camera but with HSS mode off, you will get an identical image, which shows that the same thing is happening with the RF-602 even though the flash is set with HSS on. Hope that makes sense!

What's happening I think is that the HSS flash code is not given through the central firing pin, but via the other hot shoe contacts. While the RF-602 appears to have a full set of contracts on the foot/shoe, in fact the only ones that work are the normal mode firing signal, and the wake-up signal to prime the flash with first press on the shutter release.

The long recycle time is normal with HSS because it works the flash very hard and it's basically flat out most of the time.

Thanks for taking the time to reply Richard.

I'm a little lost in your reply however.. I think I may have explained my problem incorrectly. I'm trying to have the flash fire continuously for quick shots. I'm talking 1/100 sort of speed.

This works when on board but not over wireless.

I think I may have confused high speed sync with what I was trying to explain?
 
Ah yes. Basically there is a certain amount of power in the capacitor and the gun can either deliver that in one dump or spread it out over a number of smaller powered pulses.

High Speed Sync strobes a string of very small pulses over a very short time, like 40,000 per second over a very brief period - the time it takes for the shutter to run a complete cycle at high shutter speed, usually something like 100ms or so. It is effectively continuous light for that brief period. That's what I was describing and why I think you can't do it with the RF-602.

Then there is the other strobing mode which Canon calls Multi. I don't know if your gun has this but it comes up on the control panel when you press the mode button - it goes ETTL, M (manual) and then Multi on my 580EX. In this mode you can choose how many flashes it fires, at what rate (up to 199 per sec) and at what power. This doesn't work with the RF-602 either, for the same reason.

Then there is what I think you may be wanting, which is the for the flash to keep up with the firing of the camera in continuous shooting mode, up to 6.5 frames per second on the 40D. The RF-602 will do that for as long as the flash can keep up, which of course depends on the flash, how much total power it's got, what power output it is giving, and also the state of the batteries. Basically you are asking it to recyle very quickly but it can't do much about that at high shooting rate so it's mainly just drawing on the capacitor reserve and it won't do it for very many flashes even on low power output.

If that's what you're trying to do, the RF-602 should do it but only in manual mode of course, not ETTL. On the other hand, if you hook up the flash with a dedicated cord instead of the RF-602, you will get all these functions no problem, plus full ETTL just as if the flash was on the camera. You can get massively long cords these days for a few quid - Flash In The Pan sells them on here.
 
Back
Top