Advice on filters for Nile cruise

Messages
155
Name
Neil
Edit My Images
No
Hi

I am doing a Nile cruise in November and wondered if anyone could give me some advice or suggestions what filters it would be worth taking. I am very new to photography and have no experience with filters and am getting a little confused with all the reading i've done.

So far i think i should be taking a polarizing filter.

I have a Canon 40D with a 17-85 lens and a 10-22 wide angled lens, that i'll be taking.

Any advice would be much appreciated.

Thanks
Neil
 
I've been to Egypt several times, for SCUBA diving, but only once did the touristy bit, with a couple of overnight trips to Luxor and Cairo rather than a Nile cruise. Anyway, back then I had my 30D and 17-85 lens and nothing else, and got by quite well, even selling a few shots from the trip. While not new to photography - I had been point and shooting snapshots for over a decade - I only got the 30D the week before the trip. It was quite a learning curve for me, especially when I bit the bullet and started shooting raw whilst away.

I think a CPL could be useful, but bearing in mind your two lenses have different filter sizes I think you need to consider which lens would gain grater value from a CPL. Personally I think kit might be more use on the 17-85, because at extreme wide angles (like between 10-17mm) you may well see uneven variations across the sky as the angle of view is so wide and the effect of the filter will alter across the field of view. However, if you get a 67mm filter for the 17-85 you will not be able to use it at all on the 10-22, which takes a 77mm filter. So I suggest you buy a 77mm filter and a step down ring so that you can use it on the longer lens if you wish.

Also, and this is taking you into the realms of more advanced stuff, you might want to consider having one or more ND grad filters, so that you can take the sting out of the sky and expose the foreground correctly. Depending whether you want to shoot towards or away from the sun this could make a big difference to your success.

Finally, if you want to try for some moody water shots you may want a plain ND filter so that you can achieve extended shutter speeds without stopping down too far. If you want to pursue this option, and to a lesser extent the ND grad option, you will need a tripod or some other way of securing your camera - possibly a bean bag, but none of those will be much use on a rocking boat, so may be of questionable value.

Finally, while I am not usually one to recommend the use of UV/protection filters, in the case of Egypt, which is quite dusty/sandy, it may be a wise precaution to fit one for protection when your other filters are not in use. I would also recommend using lens hoods, to combat flare and improve the protection against physical knocks, but it is a challenge to use hoods while trying to adjust a CPL, so be aware of the slight limitation there.
 
ive just got back from a nile cruise, id recomend a telephoto (something 300mm ish) for shots of the banks, lots of birds and people to shoot at, and the wide angle for in the temples, take LOADS of cards and a small bag to carry just camera and a lens its hot !! all year its hot !!

as for filters id take a polarister and a ND grad, she sky is allways blue it never rains so the skys can be blown too easy... make sure you take a rocket blower to remove dust...

anymore Q's please ask away (no piccies to show yet only been back 20 hours XD)
 
Hi Tim and chris

Thanks for the advice, i might be able to borrow a 75 - 300 lens from my business partner. I do have lens hoods for both the lenses :). Is there a make of filter that you would recommend?

In the case of the ND filter, is there a specific one? I see a lot about "stops" not really sure about them.

Thanks again
Neil
 
I would take a a good quality polarising filter, and leave it at that. A Hoya HD or Pro-1, 77mm for the 10-22, plus a 77-67 step down ring for the 17-85. Just be aware of the patchy skies you can get with a polariser and very wide angle lenses. I find it's very rarely a problem but if it is, you can tone it down by rotating the filter (although this also reduces the polarising effect) or obviously take it off.

Instead of an ND Grad, get to learn how to do HDR technique by merging two different exposures in post processing. You get much better results that way, but if you prefer to do it in-camera with an ND Grad, my choice would be a 2-stops hard cut. With grads you really need a filter holder and square filters, which I find a bit of a pain on the hoof.
 
I would take a a good quality polarising filter, and leave it at that.
Probably makes more sense. No need to over-complicate matters.

A Hoya HD or Pro-1, 77mm for the 10-22, plus a 77-67 step down ring for the 17-85.
Speaking from personal experience I'd echo the Hoya Pro-1 or HD recommendation. I had a Hoya Pro-1 CPL, broke it when I dropped my camera, replaced it with a Marumi DHG Super (which has been reviewed very favourably by Lenstip) and wish I'd stuck with Hoya.

Best price for the HD version by some margin is from Onestop-Digital....

http://www.google.co.uk/products?hl...s_occt=title&price1=&price2=&show=dd&safe=off

They're based in Hong Kong but are reliable suppliers.
 
A Step Up adapter allows you to mount a larger filter onto a lens with a smaller filter diameter. That is the type of adapter you want in order to fit a 77mm filter onto a lens with a 67mm thread.

A Step Down adapter allows you to mount a smaller filter onto a lens with a larger thread. The reason why anyone would want to do that escapes me, since almost certainly you will end up with vignetting in the corners, maybe severe.

I have to say that following that Amazon link the finish on that adapter looks pretty rough and the P&P charges seem a bit steep. Have a look here - http://www.premier-ink.co.uk/photog...-diameter/67mm-77mm-stepping-ring-p-1679.html, where the adapter is £4.99 and P&P should be £1.72. I bought my ND500 filter from them and when I bought a Vari-ND filter that turned out to perform poorly there was no bother at all sending it back for full refund. In fact they were very responsive and helpful - thread here (see post 50 and following posts).
 
Last edited:
A water filter would be the most useful thing to take!

Otherwise - antibiotics.
 
A Step Up adapter allows you to mount a larger filter onto a lens with a smaller filter diameter. That is the type of adapter you want in order to fit a 77mm filter onto a lens with a 67mm thread.

A Step Down adapter allows you to mount a smaller filter onto a lens with a larger thread. The reason why anyone would want to do that escapes me, since almost certainly you will end up with vignetting in the corners, maybe severe.

I have to say that following that Amazon link the finish on that adapter looks pretty rough and the P&P charges seem a bit steep. Have a look here - http://www.premier-ink.co.uk/photog...-diameter/67mm-77mm-stepping-ring-p-1679.html, where the adapter is £4.99 and P&P should be £1.72. I bought my ND500 filter from them and when I bought a Vari-ND filter that turned out to perform poorly there was no bother at all sending it back for full refund. In fact they were very responsive and helpful - thread here (see post 50 and following posts).

It's not always that clear cut Tim, despite the logic of what you say. I would never buy a "Stepping Ring 67-77mm" without checking by phone!

Another vote for Premier Ink though :thumbs:

PS And I've got a step-down ring ;)
 
Back
Top