Amateur photographer awarded £10K damages

This was from 2009, a lot more has been done to make sure this type of thing happens less frequently.
 
Unfortunately you get bad 'uns in every profession and the old public order trick is often the bad/frustrated Policeman's best friend.

Pleased the chap has managed to clear his name though.
 
Last edited:
The two cops should have been prosecuted for assault, there was enough documented physical evidence
 
iancandler said:
The two cops should have been prosecuted for assault, there was enough documented physical evidence

Wasn't two cops, it was just one.

There's going to be a lot more to this than the report (which is based solely on the photographers version of events) states.

Something clearly happened which resulted in officers getting hands on before they got to the station. What was that?
 
Last edited:
odd jim said:
Wasn't two cops, it was just one.

There's going to be a lot more to this than the report (which is based solely on the photographers version of events) states.

Something clearly happened which resulted in officers getting hands on before they got to the station. What was that?

It could't have been much or they would have charged him.
 
WHy does this never happen to me. I could do with an extra 10k in my pocket. Right i am off the shoot some banks.
 
fracster said:
I`m sure all the forum "Kavannagh QC wannabees" will be able to tell you...........;)

Lol!
 
ZoneV said:
It could't have been much or they would have charged him.

It was enough to restrain him to the floor and handcuff him?
 
It could't have been much or they would have charged him.

Hardly, as the CPS make that decision now, not police.

The two cops should have been prosecuted for assault, there was enough documented physical evidence

Evidence of injury isn't evidence of assault necessarily. As the article makes clear the matters still being investigated, but hey why let that get in the way, surely an article written by the Guardian is sufficient evidence to convict someone.

Of course why you probably don't know is that Solicitors often advise their clients not to co operate with a complaint investigation, as it can cause a civil claim (which is what this is) to be negated or even thrown out. But again, why let that stand in the way of the usual 'hang all police' outbursts?
 
Hardly, as the CPS make that decision now, not police.



Evidence of injury isn't evidence of assault necessarily. As the article makes clear the matters still being investigated, but hey why let that get in the way, surely an article written by the Guardian is sufficient evidence to convict someone.

Of course why you probably don't know is that Solicitors often advise their clients not to co operate with a complaint investigation, as it can cause a civil claim (which is what this is) to be negated or even thrown out. But again, why let that stand in the way of the usual 'hang all police' outbursts?

Why would a complaint need to be made for an officer to face disciplinary proceedings if he had done something wrong?

EDIT
And Bernie, i like to think i take a balanced view, but too many police / ex-police seem to do all they can to not acknowledge the problem that others see as evident in some of the police's attitude to photographers.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
odd jim said:
It was enough to restrain him to the floor and handcuff him?

Then what is the Chief Constable apologising for (edit: and admitting liability to)? They don't do it lightly.
 
Last edited:
ZoneV said:
Then what is the Chief Constable apologising for (edit: and admitting liability to)? They don't do it lightly.

Only for certain aspects of it.

If the restraint by the officers was deemed illegal they would be disciplined, and would probably have found themselves in court.

Believe you me, police officers are treated far WORSE than members of the public in that respect and the CPS will always go for a prosecution against police even if the "evidence" is VERY lacklustre in the extreme.

I know that from first hand experience (where there wasnt any evidence). So with that in mind, I suspect the hands on aspect was justified, which is why I doubt the photographer was behaving in the whiter than white way the Guardian would have you believe,

I'm not saying their initial actions were right, just that we are only hearing one side here, and it's from the Guardian after all...
 
Last edited:
As far as I can tell from reading the Guardian and Shropshire Star articles, he is to be issued a full (not partial) apology for his wrongful arrest. His brief also refers to the action as "complete resolution":

"We welcome the chief constable's decision to admit liability, to apologise and to destroy the records of Mr Finnegan's detention. We hope that this complete resolution of the claim will enable the force to learn lessons from this regrettable abuse of police powers."

It would also appear that the matter is not yet over for the officer/pcso involved. From the Shropshire Star article:

"Toby Shergold, a spokesman for West Mercia Police, said: 'This is a live matter subject to ongoing litigation and it would therefore be inappropriate to comment further at this time.' "

We shall have to wait and see but as they say, it'll all come out in the wash.
 
Last edited:
You get that from the term "complete resolution"? My interpretation would be that the chief constable simply wants that to be the end of the matter as a whole.

I should imagine the litigation is just some sort of civil action from the photographer.
 
Last edited:
What gave you the impression only a partial apology was/is to be given, Jim? I have seen no mention of this.
 
ZoneV said:
What gave you the impression only a partial apology was/is to be given, Jim? I have seen no mention of this.

When did I say that? I think we have our wires crossed.

What I meant was, it's a multi-faceted incident, with lots of different parts. It started with the approach and questioning, the 'incident' en route to the police station which resulted in him being restrained and arrested and then his continued detention at the police station.

The chief constable has offered a general apology for the arrest but clearly there were parts of this incident where the photographer didn't help himself, or otherwise why would the public order incident have arisen in the first place? It's this bit that's missing from the guardian report.

I think the apology was due to the fact the photographer should never have found himself in the situation in the first place, so leniency should therefore be given for his behaviour during the incident and any subsequent behaviour, such as him kicking off en route to the station and the subsequent arrest. That's how I read the situation at least.

But as I say, we are only getting his side of the story. The photographer has only given information on certain aspects, but didn't say what happened that led to him being taken to the floor. I'm sure the officer didn't do it just for fun?
 
Last edited:
I appreciate that Jim. We are only hearing one side and I know the Police have to deal with all sorts of characters on a daily basis, many of whom kick off etc but if this guy was one of those regular nutjobs, why wasn't he prosecuted like the rest? And why the hoo-haa - admission, record deletion, compo etc?

"He fell down the stairs, guv"?
 
Just maybe they got it wrong in this case,as has been pointed out before,the police even on duty,are not above the law.

Why to some of you the photographer is alway in the wrong :suspect:

:(
 
When did I say that? I think we have our wires crossed.

What I meant was, it's a multi-faceted incident, with lots of different parts. It started with the approach and questioning, the 'incident' en route to the police station which resulted in him being restrained and arrested and then his continued detention at the police station.

The chief constable has offered a general apology for the arrest but clearly there were parts of this incident where the photographer didn't help himself, or otherwise why would the public order incident have arisen in the first place? It's this bit that's missing from the guardian report.

I think the apology was due to the fact the photographer should never have found himself in the situation in the first place, so leniency should therefore be given for his behaviour during the incident and any subsequent behaviour, such as him kicking off en route to the station and the subsequent arrest. That's how I read the situation at least.

But as I say, we are only getting his side of the story. The photographer has only given information on certain aspects, but didn't say what happened that led to him being taken to the floor. I'm sure the officer didn't do it just for fun?

Jim you just won't face the facts,that some police offices are bad :bang:,everytime it's the photographer who is in the wrong.
And that old public order thing,any police office can use it to get out of making a mistake,or to justify their actions.
 
Last edited:
No I accept that, I was just trying to answer another posters question as to the possibilities in relation to why the officer (and pcso) were not disciplined by their force. believe you me, if they could have disciplined them they wouldn't have hesitated!

The point being it could be that while they completely misjudged the situation, there were aspects to their actions that then became reactionary to what the photographer then did.

I know there are bad cops out there, I've been the victim of a few myself over the last year or so (professionally speaking!).

I just don't think we should assume the word of this guy as fact when the report skips so many relevant details.

(mental note not to post in these endless, repetitive photographer vs police threads from here on in...)
 
Last edited:
Rapscallion

A balanced view involves waiting for an investigation (inconvienent I know) and some form of hearing, there being an old fashioned and again inconvient principle that everyone is innocent until proven guilty beyond all reasonable doubt.

I think you'll find that the investigation hasn't been concluded and there has certainly been no hearing in a Court. The officer therefore remains innocent. Not my opinion, a matter of fact.

Why does a complaint need to give evidence? Simple really, again, another quaint old tradition, it's called every person has the right to face thier accuser. And prior to prosecution, the evidence must be gathered and to an extent tested. Using your theory, if I were to for example say you have stolen my camera, then you should be immediately found guilty. Same principle.

So, in summary, my view is that instead of going off the deep end, and assuming that everything is as reported, you wait and see what comes out at the very end, not decide that Red Rum has won at the half way point. In that respect, what I said was balanced. What you said is far from it.

ZoneV

You are joking aren't you? Chief Constables appologise for everything and anything these days. As for admitting liability, I'd like to see the letter saying that, rather than trust to spin. It may be he has admitted complete liability he may not. There's nothing in the article in either paper that suggests either what was alleged or what was admitted too.
 
Bernie, how many people arrested for public order offences end up being awarded 10k with an admission of wrongful arrest?
 
I'll put mine on page 2. ;)

oi. mods arent allowed in the locking sweepstake :lol: - clear conflict of interest ;) (i'll take before the end of page 1 btw )
 
I'm pleased the discussion has gone this far without any real lunacy or anger. So often these things break down.
 
I'm sure Bernie brought up the point once before that sometimes the Police will simply make an ex-gratia payment in instances like this to save the cost of going to court.
 
Last edited:
In my original post, I put the word "SOME" in capitals for very good reason, because although I have experienced police incompetency at first hand, most of the police I have dealt with have been quite good and efficient.
It does seem however, that as the thread has progressed, some people fail to see, or rather do not wish to see the shortcomings of SOME police, whether they be PCSOs or "real ones".
Back in the eighties, one of my mates was beaten up in a busy town centre on a Saturday afternoon, by a group of skinheads. As he lay on the floor bleading from the mouth (broken jaw), some police approached and decided he was drunk and disorderly, despite members of the public ATTEMPTING to tell them what had happened. Many hours later, he was taken to a hospital and treated for his injuries.
To this day he does not trust the police.
He was not compensated in any way, and is it any wonder that he feels this way about the police?
 
I'm a little shocked that this incident took place in Shropshire, it's a county where everyone gets along (except on Saturday night where there always seems to be someone getting stabbed!)
 
I'm a little shocked that this incident took place in Shropshire, it's a county where everyone gets along (except on Saturday night where there always seems to be someone getting stabbed!)

:lol:
 
Rapscallion

A balanced view involves waiting for an investigation (inconvienent I know) and some form of hearing, there being an old fashioned and again inconvient principle that everyone is innocent until proven guilty beyond all reasonable doubt.

I think you'll find that the investigation hasn't been concluded and there has certainly been no hearing in a Court. The officer therefore remains innocent. Not my opinion, a matter of fact.

Why does a complaint need to give evidence? Simple really, again, another quaint old tradition, it's called every person has the right to face thier accuser. And prior to prosecution, the evidence must be gathered and to an extent tested. Using your theory, if I were to for example say you have stolen my camera, then you should be immediately found guilty. Same principle.

So, in summary, my view is that instead of going off the deep end, and assuming that everything is as reported, you wait and see what comes out at the very end, not decide that Red Rum has won at the half way point. In that respect, what I said was balanced. What you said is far from it.

Hi Berni, i cant help but feel you read something between the lines in my post that i didnt intend to be there...
 
In my original post, I put the word "SOME" in capitals for very good reason, because although I have experienced police incompetency at first hand, most of the police I have dealt with have been quite good and efficient.
It does seem however, that as the thread has progressed, some people fail to see, or rather do not wish to see the shortcomings of SOME police, whether they be PCSOs or "real ones".
Back in the eighties, one of my mates was beaten up in a busy town centre on a Saturday afternoon, by a group of skinheads. As he lay on the floor bleading from the mouth (broken jaw), some police approached and decided he was drunk and disorderly, despite members of the public ATTEMPTING to tell them what had happened. Many hours later, he was taken to a hospital and treated for his injuries.
To this day he does not trust the police.
He was not compensated in any way, and is it any wonder that he feels this way about the police?

I feel his pain mate, I had a similar incident in London only a year or so ago.
At a very popular metal venue(which isn't there any more...a story for another day) at Tottem Court Road. I was at the front taking pictures. There was a crowd serge and I was knocked uncontious. I'm not a small guy at 6'5 and by no means thin. I awoke outside, in handcuffs, my camera was treated as evidence and was chraged with drunk and disorely and handling stolen goods...
After about 30 mins in a van..they de-arrested me and sent me on my way..
No medical help at any time...I'm not a fan of the police...
 
Back
Top