Can someone help me get my head around reading these charts?

Messages
6,671
Name
Wail
Edit My Images
No
I am trying very hard to understand the logic from the charts here

When I look at the Tonal Range, I see the D700 beat the D3x; for the Dynamic Range, the D3x barely beats the D7000 but it’s outdone by the D700; and the same for the Colour Sensitivity, where the D700 outdoes the D3x!

If anyone can explain to me how to read these charts, and how is it that the D700 seems to be outdoing the D3x, I’d be very thankful.

Thanks in advance.





Although the link is for the three bodies, D7000, D700 and D3x, and one may argue that I should have had this in the talk equipment sub-forum; I am trying to understand the reading of the charts, which is not so dependent on the bodies but I've used these three as an example as I know these cameras rather well. However, if this thread is in the wrong sub-forum, then can someone please move it to where it ought to be. Thank you :)
 
I think the most important thing you are missing, is the launch date :)

That's 2 years of technology difference between the 3 cameras. The D7000 is current gen, and the D3x will soon be replaced by the D4 so would be considered last gen, to steal console definitions.

Also, looking at the graphs, it seems that the D7000 is out performed by the other 2 most of the time.

EDIT: At work, but i'll try and find time to have a proper look later on :)
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the input :)

I think the launch date isn't really an issue in the data given. Take out the D7000 from the list of three, and you've got the D3x, which was launched after the D700 yet the D700 seems to trump the D3x :shrug:. At least, according to how I read the charts.

But thank you for highlighting that point.
 
Don't sweat it about those charts. They're pretty much meaningless when it comes to real world photography, especially with the latest cameras.

However the results that you see are likely due to a number of factors. For a start the D3x has a sensor that has basically the same construction as a D300 sensor, except it's full frame which gives 24 or so MP. This in itself will limit the dynamic range to approximately that of a D300, but maybe better given slightly newer technology. The D700 has the same size sensor but it's only 12mp which means larger photosites, which means better light gathering abilities, which in turn means a greater dynamic range for a given sensor technology.

The D7000 has a new sensor type that has improved on the previous versions, thus leading to a better dynamic range for a given photosite density (in my mind the jury is still out on this one as I think a lot of the improvements are software related).

Hope that helps a bit.
 
Last edited:
D700 and D3x both have full frame sensors, however, the D3x is 24mp and the D700 is only 12 so I imagine that is the reason behind the differences you are seeing. :)
 
But how is it that the D700 has better dynamic range than the D3x?

More importantly, besides the 24MP vs. 12MP of the D3x vs. the D700; how is it that the D3x is supposed to be the better camera with better "results" at 3x the price, when the dynamic range, and colour sensitivity of the D700 seems to be better?

With that said, I need to ask if I'm reading these charts correctly?
 
Don't sweat it about those charts. They're pretty much meaningless when it comes to real world photography, especially with the latest cameras.

However the results that you see are likely due to a number of factors. For a start the D3x has a sensor that has basically the same construction as a D300 sensor, except it's full frame which gives 24 or so MP. This in itself will limit the dynamic range to approximately that of a D300, but maybe better given slightly newer technology. The D700 has the same size sensor but it's only 12mp which means larger photosites, which means better light gathering abilities, which in turn means a greater dynamic range for a given sensor technology.

The D7000 has a new sensor type that has improved on the previous versions, thus leading to a better dynamic range for a given photosite density (in my mind the jury is still out on this one as I think a lot of the improvements are software related).

Hope that helps a bit.

Hi,

Sorry, I hadn't seen your post when I replied to Harvey Nikon; and I read what you're saying, which is along the lines what Harvey is saying too.

But, I wonder if I am reading the charts right; and as I've explain in my above post ... how is it that the D3x isn't out performing the D700 when it really ought to? After all, the D3x is supposed to be a far better camera for landscape and glamour due to its' (supposedly) better performance at lower ISO. However, from the charts, it seems that the D700 is outdoing it :shrug:

So, to put my question in a different way; from reading these charts, what makes the D3x a better camera, other than a bigger sensor which allows for better cropping?
 
What you're missing is that the higher resolution sensor doesn't just allow you to crop more.

What the chart is telling is that if you're viewing images produced by both cameras at 100% on screen, then the D3x will, pixel for pixel, be slightly noisier.

However, if you're printing at the same size, then the visible effect of any increased noise will be smaller from the higher resolution image. You've got twice as many pixels at your disposal on the D3x than you do on the D700 to produce a square centimetre of printed image, so you can halve the effective noise level in a print.

That's the balance to be struck between higher resolution and increase noise associated with denser pixels on the sensor. If you can keep ahead of the game by increasing resolution without increasing the SNR by the same ratio, then you've got a better performer.

edit: I've just noticed they have a 'Print' comparison where they D700 and D3x are on a par with each other, which fits with what I'm saying.
 
Last edited:
Thanks Rob :)

But what about the Dynamic Range? I can't seem to see how any of the Nikon range can out perform the D3x on that reading .. yet, even the older D700 does :shrug:!
 
But what about the Dynamic Range? I can't seem to see how any of the Nikon range can out perform the D3x on that reading .. yet, even the older D700 does :shrug:!

Are you reading the same charts as me?

At low ISO, the D3x has the edge by a whisker on the 'Screen' chart and nearly a stop on 'Print'.

From ISO 800 on the D700 bests the D3x by a little under a stop on 'Screen' and it's negligible on 'Print'. For landscape, though, you'll not be likely to be using ISO 1600 anyhow.

Consider that when you're shooting slide (the traditional realm of landscape photographers using film) you've got perhaps six to eight stops of DR. 13 stops at ISO 100 gives plenty of room for practical purposes.
 
Do yourself a favour, buy a Canon!!

:lol: :lol: :lol:


Are you reading the same charts as me?

At low ISO, the D3x has the edge by a whisker on the 'Screen' chart and nearly a stop on 'Print'.

From ISO 800 on the D700 bests the D3x by a little under a stop on 'Screen' and it's negligible on 'Print'. For landscape, though, you'll not be likely to be using ISO 1600 anyhow.

Consider that when you're shooting slide (the traditional realm of landscape photographers using film) you've got perhaps six to eight stops of DR. 13 stops at ISO 100 gives plenty of room for practical purposes.

I believe we are reading the same charts, since what you've explained is what I am seeing.

True, it does show the D3x to be better at ISO 200, plus there is the workable range at ISO 100 (for the D3x); and true that I would not be using ISO 400 yet alone 800 or more.

But still, I can't seem to understand how from ISO 400 the two are so close and from ISO 800 the D700 has the upper hand :thinking:. I would have thought the D3x to be far far far better than anything else in the workable ISO range :shrug:

So, in the end can I rightly say I have been reading these charts correctly :shrug: :thinking:?
 
BTW, while the D700 came out after the D3x, there's only six months between them. They're essentially on the same product cycle, while the D7000 is a generation behind.

Don't sweat it about those charts. They're pretty much meaningless when it comes to real world photography

TBH, that's about my view.

As I said in both my last posts, when you compare the Print charts (which is what counts at the end of the day) there's a marginal difference in performance between the D3x and D700 for regular size printing.

You've got to look at the other things that the cameras offer to decide which fits your style of photography.

I'm a Canon shooter. If you stack the 5D Mk II up against the 1Ds Mk III, they're practically identical on the same set of charts (and even have the same 21 Mpx resolution) but the 1Ds is nearly twice as expensive. Technical charts aside, other features are much more important factors in buyers' decisions.
 
But still, I can't seem to understand how from ISO 400 the two are so close and from ISO 800 the D700 has the upper hand :thinking:. I would have thought the D3x to be far far far better than anything else in the workable ISO range

I think...

The ISO is effected by the number of MP, the more the worse the ISO performance (not including in camera noise reduction etc). You need to read how sensors work, and I haven't got time to find links etc right now.

But as the D700 has lower MP, it handles the light better. So gives, better ISO performance.

Again, that is pretty much what I think from what I understand :)
 
You have to realise that there are different reasons that a pro body will be preffered by a pro, and it's not all about ISO performance. You have to take into account things like durability, auto focus and metering capabilities. In the case of the D3x resolution is important if you are doing fashion magazine spreadf, there isnt much point paying the extra if you are a wedding photographer but if you need that extra res then its everything.

You know why I am using the D3 instead of the D700? the D700 only has one CF card slot, that means I can't backup as I shoot and that is important. Theres other reasons, I like the bigger body without adding a grip, etc but its not all about the numbers.
 
Oh and I have been looking at the D7000 for its video capabilites, Nikon better get their act together on that front or I will be picking up a canon for that side of things. Wont be making the switch completely but I'm sure once I've got the body and some glass a switch wouldn't seem like such a big jump.

Actually what you are seeing is the pro features going into the prosumer models very quickly and in some cases just about outperforming them because the manafacturers are all about making money. The market for that level of gear is massive and the manafacturers dont mind shafting the pros by making everything that was developed for the pro market available in lower end gear and even putting more R and D into the consumer gear than into the gear that made their reputations.
 
Oh and I have been looking at the D7000 for its video capabilites, Nikon better get their act together on that front or I will be picking up a canon for that side of things. Wont be making the switch completely but I'm sure once I've got the body and some glass a switch wouldn't seem like such a big jump.

Rumours for the new gen of Nikons offer:

Full HD 1920x1080p (24, 25, 30, 50, 60fps) with Stereo sound & AF

I will definitely be getting the D800 or D4 if this is the case :)
 
Rob / Harvey / Graham,

Thank you all, the input is very useful :thumbs:

It seems that I am reading the charts correctly, then :). Somehow I would have thought the D3x had these qualities, over all of the other Nikon DSLRs ...

- Better dynamic range at all ISO within its' workable range
- Better colour sensitivity, and
- Better tonal range

These, plus the other factors that the pro. body gives it (more robust body and shutter mechanism, better metering, bigger and brighter viewfinder, better weather sealing, more powerful processor, and the dual memory card slot).

Again, thank you for your time and input.

I hope the D4 comes out pretty soon, and that it is just as ground-breaking as the D3 was when it was released.
 
Back
Top