I like the DOF on number 1 like yourself. But the colour doesn't seem right to me :shrug: I always think of cherry tomatoes to be a deep red colour, but these look orange and on top of that there seems to be a yellow cast over them. Did you shoot in RAW? If so you could change your WB to tungsten if you wanted.
More is less I thought Karin #1 for me, with a slice of honey roast ham and 2 slices of freshly cut bloomer and butter.
I think #1 works best, they do look tasty
#1 for me.
Jenny.
I prefer #1 also. #2 is a little too DoF for me and I don't think the composition is as good in #3. Nicely sliced, are you are a mistress of cuisine as well as photography?
Now that's a better colour. Certainly looks more natural, and the plate under is showing white now, where as that looked yellow before. Nice one
I like #1, then #3. I have some cherries on my desk. Shame it's not a camera day (off out tonight where I don't like leaving it)
I don't mean to sound rude (so please don't take it this way), but #2 looks like a dodgy shot that I might have taken. It doesn't really do anything
#1, but the tomatoes do look a bit over ripe (greeny orange) I would colour correct this, food photography needs to look fresh and perfect.
i'm going to guess israilie tomatoes. possibly spanish.
I think Chris is right,
A small contrast and saturation boost, 10% of each.