Dilemma: When are you 'good' enough to upgrade to full frame?

Messages
246
Edit My Images
Yes
Like many working people, I simply do not get to practice photography as much as I'd like. I'm doing something about it though and am applying to go part-time in my main job.

But as much as I enjoy seeing other people's shots be they on this brilliant forum or in magazines, I always come away feeling pretty depressed that I never seem to 'get it'. I try and try yet very few pix I take are ever worth posting due to some kind of dumb mistake that I can spot myself after the event.

But going part-time in the real job means that I want to upscale my freelance job (magazine contributor), and start taking photography more seriously.

I'm thinking of course of going for the EOS 5D MkII. For the kind of photography I do (static, magazine quality) it looks just perfect. I would wait at LEAST six months for the price to come down, but to spend £4k upgrading to this is an eye-watering investment, and quite simply I don't think my level is high enough to justify such an outlay. And of course I am about to half my main source of income.

My Nikon D80 manages to produce magazine covers and content pics that the publishers are happy with. These are low-circulation special interest mags and not fine art, graphic, or lifestyle titles.

Do I wait, do I invest, or is this a chicken/egg scenario? :shrug:

Any thoughts anyone?

Thanks in advance,
 
Why do you need the mark II, the 5D is available now for less than 1/2 the money

Also why change brands, you already have some Nikon glass, possibly a flash so why not just get the D700 if you want full frame
 
Changing you gear won't make you a better photographer. You said yourself that you take very few photos worth posting and that you make mistakes that you don't pick up on till after the fact...so get more practice in, learn your camera, learn how best to change the settings on the fly to suit what your shooting etc and then once you have outgrown your current gear, think about upgrading.

That's my advice, especially as your about to halve your income!
 
Why do you need the mark II, the 5D is available now for less than 1/2 the money

Also why change brands, you already have some Nikon glass, possibly a flash so why not just get the D700 if you want full frame

Thanks for the replies.

I forgot to add that I'm not really happy with my Tamron Wide Angle lens... focus is a little 'soft', and it's the lens I use for 80% of what I do. I may just upgrade that for now.

The 21MP of the MKII would put me ahead of the competition of the freelancers in my game, most of whom use kit like mine or the D700/5D MKI. Art editors would find the images more useful in this size as they may be cropped to their style and still be large enough for printing at 300dpi.

Practice, practice, practice I guess...
 
The 21MP of the MKII would put me ahead of the competition of the freelancers in my game

what game are you in?:)
 
I would only consider 'going full frame' if the bulk of what I did was wide-angle landscapes or portrait/fashion work. Anything longer than 100mm, and you're probably better off using a crop sensor camera.
 
You can pre-order the 5DMK2 for £3K and the price will come down rapidly soon after it becomes widely available. There's some confused thinking going on though if you think you need to be 'good enough' to use full frame or that it's necessarily an 'upgrade'. You go full frame if you need the extra FOV for the bulk of work you do.

Full frame is very unforgiving of lens quality though and you should probably be thinking about upgrading your lens if you're seriously thinking about full frame.
 
My main passion in life is kitesurfing. I upgraded my kites this year and wish I'd done it years ago... I was held back by my old, outdated kit. Hence the question, but it appears that in the field of photography this is much less of a factor.

A colleague of mine upgraded to an EOS 5D a few years ago and has since started getting 'photographic only' commissions. And she has won the 'photographer' class of our industry's 'Journalist of the Year' Awards two years running. She says that the 5D helped immeasurably.

My line of work? OK, time to come clean... caravans and (hopefully) touring features.

So, magazine covers:

coverC.jpg



Touring feature shots:

536.jpg



001copy-1.jpg



But mainly caravan interiors:

wshrmlight12copy.jpg



kit12copy.jpg




Completely agree about needing 'decent' glass and hanging fire for a good few months for the prices to come down... it's just a balance between when skill levels are high enough and investing in the future; :thinking: WHEN is the right time... 6 months, 12 months, 18 months, never? :bang:
 
it's just a balance between when skill levels are high enough and investing in the future; :thinking: WHEN is the right time... 6 months, 12 months, 18 months, never? :bang:

You answered that yourself...

I upgraded my kites this year and wish I'd done it years ago... I was held back by my old, outdated kit.
Once your kit is holding you back from what you want to achieve, it's then time to buy new kit that will allow you to do what you want.
 
I can see how a full frame may help your work but 12mp would surely be fine why would you need 21mp for your line of work?
 
that caravan is nicer than my house

:lol: Surely not! Caravans are staid, boring, basic, draughty and outmoded, aren't they? Or is that just the opinion of people who think that Clarkson is cool and base their educated opinions on a 30-year old Carry-on film? ;)


Magazines are printed at 300dpi and larger file sizes are good. So if an art editor gets two pix of that kitchen above, one at 12MP and one at 21MP, she may not be able to crop out for example just the cooker if she wants with the 12MP, but could with the 21MP. I don't want to tread on the toes of the lady photographer in the industry that I very much admire (besides, she might be reading this forum!) but am trying to retain a competitive edge over other freelancers in the industry, many of whom are still using 'Prosumers'.

And another thing! Competition between magazines as well as between freelancers becomes ever more fierce. Leisure mags are upping the bar as regards to photo quality, to the point that on a couple of touring features I'm doing next year I have to endure the humility of having a pro sent to do the shots. I always assist of course and learn, but ultimately would like to be able to replicate such quality and be a more attractive (and worthy of a higher page rate) contributor for the publisher.

Back to square one though eh? Practice, practice, practice...
 
You're "good" enough to upgrade when you are "good" enough to spend £2-3k on a body and then pony up for a new set of lenses.

If you feel that you "need" an ff camera and it will pay for itself, then it's a business investment not a luxury....
 
i really dont like caravan's

well i like them if there cool and in a show room, but not on the road, or at campsites.

tent or campervan is the winner
 
You've missed one major point here applicable to your line of work. You shoot caravan interiors. This requires a wide angle. Full frame gives you a wider angle than a standard dslr.
 
Full frame is very unforgiving of lens quality though and you should probably be thinking about upgrading your lens if you're seriously thinking about full frame.

:agree:

Very good advice
 
Like many working people, I simply do not get to practice photography as much as I'd like. I'm doing something about it though and am applying to go part-time in my main job.

But as much as I enjoy seeing other people's shots be they on this brilliant forum or in magazines, I always come away feeling pretty depressed that I never seem to 'get it'. I try and try yet very few pix I take are ever worth posting due to some kind of dumb mistake that I can spot myself after the event.

But going part-time in the real job means that I want to upscale my freelance job (magazine contributor), and start taking photography more seriously.

I'm thinking of course of going for the EOS 5D MkII. For the kind of photography I do (static, magazine quality) it looks just perfect. I would wait at LEAST six months for the price to come down, but to spend £4k upgrading to this is an eye-watering investment, and quite simply I don't think my level is high enough to justify such an outlay. And of course I am about to half my main source of income.

My Nikon D80 manages to produce magazine covers and content pics that the publishers are happy with. These are low-circulation special interest mags and not fine art, graphic, or lifestyle titles.

Do I wait, do I invest, or is this a chicken/egg scenario? :shrug:

Any thoughts anyone?

Thanks in advance,

I'm going to go off topic for a second (sorry), but I was just curious... how did you find that job shooting for the magazine?
 
£100 or so will get you an F80, more will get you a better film body. Spend a few hundred on a good neg scanner and there you have your FF kit (lenses not included...). Almost certainly cheaper than any of the current FF bodies, although you will lose the immediacy of digital.
 
changing from crop to FF has nothing to do with ablity. you change because you want something that FF offers.
 
i would say if you are shooting in a confind space its not if you class yourself as "good enough" but more of the fact that you will get better and more in your shot with a FF.
anyone is good enough to use one just if you want to fork out the money for the beast
 
Dude i kite for EH and i take all the pictures for promotion with the owner of the company, eric. We both use cropped bodies and we get all our stuff in kiteworld. Honestly wont make a difference in the kiting aspect. You can get a big f-16 in frame on short line, but kitesurfing photography for mags of pros is all about the set up... If were shooting something everyone ride 20m lines so we can get kites into shots :D
 
Personally I'd upgrade the wide angle lens first. If the editor wants to crop and the image is soft, then they are going to bounce it, and this may put a doubt in their minds about other images.

Unless you are going to do a lot of DPS pics then I would suggest that around 12MP is sufficient, and to be honest it will probably take a DPS anyway. I know my 5D has.

Also have a look at Nikon's offerings. You seem happy with Nikon so stick with it.
 
Do it, you shouldn't have really come and asked on here if your so adiment about upgrading to a full frame.

Your opinion, your not going to budge, your choice, you think you need a 21MP camera for your line of work? Do it, your money, your photos, your decision.
 
Back
Top