Discerning eye color in photographs

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lightman
  • Start date Start date
L

Lightman

Guest
Hi guys,

I've been having a discussion on another website with someone who insists that Paul McCartney has brown eyes, inspite of the fact that his eyes are documented to be hazel.

In order to prove their claim, they post endless photos of Paul McCartney and insist they show him with brown eyes.

Here are a few:

cap151.jpg
22ps.jpg

pmagclose.jpg


To me, those photos do not show whether his eyes are brown or hazel.

But I'd like to get an independent view on these photos and on your views on the reliability of old, low resolution photos as regards their accuracy in displaying the true eye color of a person.

Thanks in advance.
 
1) Brown
2) Can't really tell
3) Hazel!

That averages out at I haven't got a clue! :p
 
Isn't Hazel just a subdivision of Brown?

I'm a bloke, so don't know the difference between the two!
 
Not meaning to get weird here but isn't there some kind of bizarre conspiracy theory that suggests Mcartney died in a car crash in the 90's and he has been replaced by a body double! Maybe that explains the discrepancy, cough cough.
 
I would say they are more hazey than hazel............... :nuts:
 
Sorry about the large file. Didn't realise that before posting.

Anyway, it just goes to show that one of them is in fact red.
 
Thanks for your comments guys.

Yeah, you are correct. I'm having a debate in a thread where various people believe Paul McCartney died in 1966 and was replaced by a double.

In order to 'prove' this, they keep posting photos which they claim show Paul had hazel eyes and his double had brown eyes.

For anyone interested, you can view the thread here:

http://www.davidicke.com/forum/showthread.php?t=30205&page=122

I just wanted to get some opinions from photo experts as to the realibility of photos when it comes to judging eye colour - things like lighting, different cameras, angles distance from the camera etc.
 
Back
Top