Do i need an UWA lens if i have the 15-85mm

Messages
1,940
Name
Dini
Edit My Images
Yes
I recently purchased the 15-85mm lens to replace my 17-85mm. The lens is great but i am wondering if i should get the 10-22mm for the ultra wide angle.

Is there really a big difference between 10mm and 15mm?

If anyone has both these lenses would you mind posting sample shots of the same scene taken at the widest focal length from both lenses just so that i can get an idea as to the difference between the two.

Thanks
 
I would be fairly happy with 15mm. Do you often find yourself saying I wish I had 5mm less when taking you shots ?
 
That 5mm does make quite a big difference though!
 
Only you can really say what you need!

Do you find yourself stepping back because you can't fit everything you want in your shot?
 
As a 15-85 owner, I've decided the 10-22 is likely to be my next purchase. It's raved about on here.
 
I tried to compare the difference between 15mm and 20mm just to get an idea of the difference but someone is telling me that the wider the focal length the bigger the difference. I think what he means is if the difference from 15mm to 20mm is lets say 2 meters, it wouldnt mean that the difference between 10mm and 15mm will also be 2 meters so i cant use the 15mm to 20mm range as an example. Is this correct?

Also, i have been looking at other posts and i get the impression that a lot of people with the 10-22mm dont always use the 10mm focal length. They usually start at 15mm and above because of the distortion. I dont know how true this is though.

ps. Have a look at my flickr page (see signature) to get an idea of the kind of shots i do. All were taken with the 17-85mm as i have only just got the 15-85mm. The first few pages were from Athens where an UWA would have definitely been very usefull but then again i dont go to Athens every week :) If i remember correctly, the only times where i think i wish i had a lens that was wider than the 17mm is when i am holiday.
 
I have a 10-22 and shoot mainly landscapes. The vast majority of my shots are taken at 10mm. It opens up a whole new perspective to wide angle photography and can add a lot of foreground impact. There can be some distortion at 10 and 11mm, but this can be corrected in DPP.
If you have not already read it, then I added a review for this lens in the appropiate section of TP.
 
ziggy©;3540851 said:
I tried to compare the difference between 15mm and 20mm just to get an idea of the difference but someone is telling me that the wider the focal length the bigger the difference. I think what he means is if the difference from 15mm to 20mm is lets say 2 meters, it wouldnt mean that the difference between 10mm and 15mm will also be 2 meters so i cant use the 15mm to 20mm range as an example. Is this correct?

Think of it this way, if you where shown 2 pictures, 25mm apart 1 at 300mm and one art 325mm, you'd probably have to look for a second or 2 to see which was which. Now do the same with a 10mm and a 35mm and you'll see instantly which is which. The shorter the focal length the bigger the change a small change in focal length makes.
 
Why not just hire the lens for a weekend go out and have a play with them both, if the results impress you then you’re saving for an expensive lens. If on the other hand you find that you don’t really need the extra 5mm then you’ve saved yourself a small fortune.
 
ziggy© said:
I tried to compare the difference between 15mm and 20mm just to get an idea of the difference but someone is telling me that the wider the focal length the bigger the difference. I think what he means is if the difference from 15mm to 20mm is lets say 2 meters, it wouldnt mean that the difference between 10mm and 15mm will also be 2 meters so i cant use the 15mm to 20mm range as an example. Is this correct?

Also, i have been looking at other posts and i get the impression that a lot of people with the 10-22mm dont always use the 10mm focal length. They usually start at 15mm and above because of the distortion. I dont know how true this is though.

ps. Have a look at my flickr page (see signature) to get an idea of the kind of shots i do. All were taken with the 17-85mm as i have only just got the 15-85mm. The first few pages were from Athens where an UWA would have definitely been very usefull but then again i dont go to Athens every week :) If i remember correctly, the only times where i think i wish i had a lens that was wider than the 17mm is when i am holiday.

It's not distortion at 10mm is perspective, massive difference!

There's no point in buying a 10-22 and never shooting at 10mm as this is why you buy one in the 1st place, only shooting at 15mm and above is nonsense!
 
I used to use a Sigma 10-20 on my 50D, and after the initial period of using 10mm for everything I tended to settle on using it at around 15mm for a lot of shots.

With my 5Dmii I use a Zeiss 21mm which is the equivalent of around 13mm and I find this to be wide enough. Even 24mm (eq. 15mm on 1.6x) is pretty wide.
 
Back
Top