does anybody take notice of competition themes?

What about the other 64% then? :p

Everybody will read the theme differently, those who read it wrongly probably won't win!
 
Dunno,
but I think the amateur shots are all a lot better than the 'professional' ones.
Anyway, don't the NT have strict rules about requiring a license for any photography on their site, if for commercial reasons or non-private use? (i.e. public competition!)
 
theme: 'A competition to capture visitors enjoying the National Trust's great outdoor spaces.'

http://myphoto.nationaltrust.org.uk/

I'd say about 30% of the entries actually have people in them, and about 5% show people enjoying themselves, and about 1% are in a NT OUTDOOR space.

i have put around 25 on it...and i can see as i went over the entries that there are a very lot...and i am amongst them that think a beautiful shot is all that is required
i dont expect to get anywhere with those but my next nt outing will definately have people and places as a theme
its gluttony and a tendency to gorge everything you did well into the pot
the judges must puke with the sweetness of it all...and no vision
 
just a point...some nt areas wont come up on the search tap
i did 2 on snowdonia...and didnt get any recognition names scrolling up
i think mow cop was another
this could fox some foxes...erm folks
 
What about the other 64% then? :p

Someone didn't read the OP very well!

The 70% (not 64 as I suspect the "people enjoying themselves" are shots with people in, no?) was kind of the point of the original post - most of the photos don't fit the theme.
 
Someone didn't read the OP very well!

The 70% (not 64 as I suspect the "people enjoying themselves" are shots with people in, no?) was kind of the point of the original post - most of the photos don't fit the theme.



Could it reflect on the quality of the entries if so few of them actually fulfilled the brief?
 
People spoil outdoor shots. :p (Actually others must agree with me as the favourite shot don't seem to have anybody in them!)

I assume there is no limit to the entries (i.e. you can enter more than one)? Can't find any reference to the number of entries.
 
Someone didn't read the OP very well!

The 70% (not 64 as I suspect the "people enjoying themselves" are shots with people in, no?) was kind of the point of the original post - most of the photos don't fit the theme.

I've only looked through a small number of the 4292 entries, but most of them had people in. Ok, you couldn't see their faces in all them... many were in the distance... but well, they wouldn't be there if they weren't enjoying it. The brief didn't say you had to be able to see the smiles of said people.

Each person as I said will read the theme differently and put their own twist on it.

As for the OPs %s... it's pretty difficult to tell what is and what isn't NT space unless you have visited every NT site... so where he gets 1% from is beyond me. The photos I looked through had far more people in than 30% and I'm guessing they were all enjoying themselves... at least more than 5% definitely were! Bearing in mind 20% of the population are NT members... plus the visitors such as myself who aren't actually signed up... the numbers say it all ;) I know why I go to NT properties, and it isn't to bore myself!
 
Wow, don't want to be harsh, but the pro's photos are rubbish for the theme + quality.
I would use 1 as leaflet/advert material.
Some are are good shots but don't really fit the theme.

A quick browse on the general entries and you can find lots of pics of *** enjoying nature, not sure if they are on NT grounds, but some good shots there.
 
Gary has a fair point (although his numbers might be a bit out :naughty:)... I went onto the home page and it flicks up 10 random photos from submissions. The 1st time I did it only one photo had people in it (or the essence of people in the shot)...for the rest there was no way you could interpret them as 'on theme'.

2nd time I did it about 50% had people in....so I guess its luck of the draw when you visit the home page.

Ive just added 4 photos on NT property...all of which have people in the shot :)
 
hope we do get some results
the top voted shot has one person...face not seen...but a kid..ahhhhhh
and not a really good coverage of NT stuff
but judges will be judges and themes are themes

people and places...a broad brush..
 
hope we do get some results
the top voted shot has one person...face not seen...but a kid..ahhhhhh
and not a really good coverage of NT stuff
but judges will be judges and themes are themes

people and places...a broad brush..

Exactly, it depends if you look at the longer theme on the home page (which I actually didn't find for a while even though I knew it was there:bonk:) or that of the entry page (in bold). One means people in the shot, the other just says (IMO) people in a place, or the place itself...
 
Back
Top