Ever had a card fail?

Have you ever had a card fail, and could you recover the images?

  • Never had a failure

    Votes: 97 66.9%
  • Had a failure on a cheap card, recovered the images

    Votes: 7 4.8%
  • Had a failure on a cheap card, couldn't recover the images

    Votes: 12 8.3%
  • Had a failure on a branded card, recovered the images (Kingston, Sandisk, etc)

    Votes: 16 11.0%
  • Had a failure on a branded card, couldn't recover the images (Kingston, Sandisk, etc)

    Votes: 13 9.0%

  • Total voters
    145
Only card failure I ever had was when 1st starting out. I had been using card prob 3 occasions. I was then doing some house cleaning on p.c. and decided to re-format my card. In the p.c. slot. ***! why I dont know it just seemed like a good idea. It would not work in the camera again.
I am lead to believe its a different format process, never found out true reason but since then, 10 years on, never had anothe fail once I have down loaded and backed up pics I use the camera to clean and format.
Back in the days of yore I was the proud owner of FUJI cameras. One day ,like a fool I formatted the card in my PC. Never worked after that. It wouldn`t reformat in the camera. I just threw it in the drawer. Some time later I purchased a Fuji 602 camera. I put this card in, and guess what, it formatted OK.
 
1 Random failure on a 4gig kingston card. Was sitting in a drawer for a month. Popped it into the camera...corrupt. Worked perfectly before that for about 1.5 years.
 
Personally, I have never had a failure with any card. I always buy decent media though. Currently using a 8Gb Sandisk Extreme 60Mb/s UDMA CF card.

At work, I've seen a few failed shots on cards and couldn't recover the images. Not sure on the make but without doubt they would've been cheap ones and were probably used again after a quick format. :lol:
 
Card failures on various cards, Sandisk, Kingston...

Initially put down as card faults, but later couldn't exclude a fault with the camera ??

All images recovered on each occation, but I had try different software until I got one that actually worked.
 

I've only had one failure and it lost me an entire studio session around 4 years ago. It was while using a 1GB Lexar Pro CF card with a 20D. I failed to recover any of the images and so as a precaution I replaced the two Lexar cards I'd previously used with a couple of Sandisk cards.

I have stuck with Sandisk since and currently use a mix of their new 8GB, 30Mb/s Ultras and some older 4GB 30Mb/s Extreme IIIs with no problems. I've also used an 8GB Transcend CF card for the best part of a year with no problems.
 
I've been using CF cards for about 17 years (I've still got my first 0.008 GB card) and the only one that's failed on me was one I was using in a PDA - and I removed it while it was being written to, so I can't really blame the card for that.

I've just bought a 32GB Sandisk. I'd much rather have all my eggs in one very safe basket, rather than trying to juggle several baskets of eggs.
 
I used to have a few MyMemory 2Gb CF cards which used to corrupt the odd frame, especially during a continuous shooting sequence. :( They were supposedly fast cards too.

I only use Sandisk now, and haven't had any problems. I wouldn't go with too large capacities though, just in case. ;)
 
I had a Kingston 4gb card fail last week, I managed to recover the images as a thumbnail but they wouldn't open in lightroom or cs3. I now save to cf card and sd card in camera!
 
Back
Top