It really depends on what you are planning on doing with it, do you need the extra stop of light over the f1.8, if so it's a no brainer and there would be no point in even considering the f2.8 zoom which is 2 1/3 stops slower. If not and you want it for sports, fast action then you need to be looking at either the f2.8 zoom or a 135L f2 (brilliant lens, great IQ, smallish, light, not too pricey and very fast focussing). If you need the versatility of the zoom with a fast max aperture then again it's a no brainer, the f2.8 Mk2 reigns but if you can do without the f2.8 the 70-200L f4 IS is as good optically and has a similar IS system but is considerably lighter and cheaper.
I went from an 85mm f1.8 to a 85L Mk1 and thought it was fantastic, I later sold it and regretted it immediately.
I now have the 85L Mk2 and whilst the focussing is slightly faster, the image quality is not really any better and therefore not really worth the price premium in my opinion. If you can find a S/h Mk1 then that may be the way to go.
I have all of the lenses I mentioned, the 85L Mk2, the 135L f2, the new 70-200L f2.8 IS Mk2 and the 70-200L f4 IS, if I was to purchase them again to use on FF, I would go 135L (+1.4x extender), 85L and 70-200L f2.8 Mk2.
The 135L and 85L lenses give you a image quality that is difficult to replicate with the non L Canon lenses, they have better build quality, IQ, colour rendition and usually better feel in use, but they are also larger, heavier and more expensive, but like all things quality does not come cheap or without complications.
Some images taken with the 85L Mk1 and 135L.