Help on choosing Fisheye / Wide Lens

Messages
89
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi guys

Dont post on here very often if at all but use the site regularly for info as there's always loads of good information but I'm being a bit of a numpty and cant find the info I need so forgive me if this is in the wrong section.

Basically ive been asked to take photo's of my parents barn conversion as its developed and i've got to a point where my widest lens an 18-55 just doesnt cut it and I cant get the rooms in properly.

I was thinking of taking a few shots and stitching them together in photoshop but I fancy a new lens so was thinking of a fisheye but I'm not sure what to look at.

I've seen the Nikon 10mm F2.8 but at £500+ new it seems a lot for something I may or may not use! Will I notice much difference if I went for the Tamron 10-24mm, I know its not as fast but its over £150 cheaper.

Basically can anyone point me in the direction or recommend a lens for my D3000 that will enable me to shoot super wide.

Cheers
 
If you are taking photos of rooms do not worry about the speed of the lens. You should invest in a tripod and have a longer shutter speed. I haven't used any ultra wide lens so cannot recommend any.
 
Dave got a tripod so all good there and happy with long exposures its just getting the whole damn room in :bang:

Looking around it looks like I have the choice of nikon 10-24mm which is hugely expensive, the sigma 10-20mm or tamron 10-24mm so ive anyone has any experience of these It would be much apprecaited :thinking:
 
Steve - the Nikon 10.5mm is an amazing piece of kit; as well made as any high-end pro glass and the optics, for what it is and what it costs, are first rate. However, you've hit on the major point about fisheyes, and that's how much use will justify the purchase.

There is a thread here discussing cheap alternatives to the OEM and 3rd-party fisheye lenses.

I know Tokina does a 10-17mm that is called a fisheye but having never seen one, I don't know how much fisheye effect it produces. The Nikon 10.5mm is a proper fisheye, producing wildly distorted, wide-angle images that can be proper funky and failrly easy to correct in terms of making verticals a bit straighter.

This is the kind of thing you can expect from it. Bear in mind the bank at the bottom of the frame is straight, so that gives you an idea of just how much it can get in shot:


Fighting To The End by Pat MacInnes, on Flickr
 
I wouldn't want a fisheye for indoor shots, but Ultra wide would be good. I had to shoot my parents' place for the website, so got a cheap 19-35mm lens and Pentax SLR and did it on film with flash. Worked a treat!
 
The widest I've shot at is 15mm and tbh, even at 15mm you do get some distortion of uprights around the edges of the image so I guess this would get worse the shorter the lens it. Not sure how useful a wider lens would be if you're only going to use it for interior shots as I'd have thought you'd want an accurate representation of the room rather than an "artistic" distorted affect.

Perhaps you could try sticking with the 18mm, take a number of shots and stitch them togther in PP?
 
There's the Tokina 11-16 and 12-24 for normal wide angle lens. Both reported to be excellent picture quality.
 
Suggest you just keep an eye out for a s/h nikon 10.5/2.8 one - as others have said it's a wonderfully made lens

I paid 300 notes delivered for a boxed mint one off eBay a couple of months back at this sort of price you might as well have the genuine nikon item
 
Just to clarify for the op, an ultra wide angle lens and a fisheye are two entirely different beasts. Something like the Tamron mentioned will, at 10mm, give a field of view of roughly 97°, whereas with a fisheye such as the Nikon 10.5mm it is more like 180° which will produce images with curved horizons as per the image above, although it is quite possible to "correct" this in something like photoshop to provide a normal shot, if that is what's required.
 
Back
Top