I am considering selling my 100-400 for 70-200 f2.8 is this wise

Messages
332
Name
john
Edit My Images
Yes
I am considering p/e my canon 100-400 and a couple of other lens for a 70-200 f/2.8. Im not sure yet if i go for the is model or non is, or even the much cheaper sigma with os. I already have 24-105 and 500f/4 as i used to shoot quite a lot of wildlife.I think in the long term canon would hold its price better and i have to think in future terms. also I have the 1x4 and 2x canon converters and i know i would loose a couple of stops if used with the 70-200.I have recently been doing more walk round kind of shooting ,so im thinking the 70-200 would be good for this. But if i p/e the 100-400 am i going backwards and selling it and a couple of other lens just on a sort of whim, and we all get them. Would it be a silly thing to do or should i go for the expensive canon with is.If i did this i would never be in a position to buy another 100-400 . My reason for posting this is im going nuts trying to think whats best to do. I know everyones circumstances are different and only i can make the decision .But i thought maybee there is something i have not considered or missed here .I thank you for taking time to read this and any comments would be good.
 
I owned 100-400 and loved it, but when canon 70-200 f2.8 Is came along I never used the 100-400 so sold it and defo don't regret it. I will be getting x2 convertor soon for times when extra reach is needed.
 
Thanks urdy,I know its owners preference and with a couple of other lenses i will sell i can afford to get either the canon non is or at a push , the sigma with o/s . But if i go for the canon with i/s i am having to sell the 100-400 ,thats my dilemma. Age not being on my side either and soon comming up to retirement with no spare money ,im just asking what others would think .As i said maybee there is something i havent considered or missed. I usually do. ha ha .
 
I had a 100-400 and also a sigma 70-200 f2.8, didnt use the canon more than a dozen times in 2 yrs so sold it and bought a 1.4 convertor for the sigma, never missed the 100-400
 
70-200 range is so versatile, where 100-400 is much more specific/specialist. You're not using that indoors. the 70-200, you very much can. The 70-200 with a 2x TC is probably still as good if not better than the 100-400. I don't shoot Canon though, just guessing.
 
I had a 100-400 for airshows and wildlife but eventually sold it, after cpmparing it against a Sigma 150-500 OS I found the Sigma was more than adequate for my needs (I must of got a good one). I've since got a 70-200 2.8 IS MkII and a 2x MkIII converter and I'm using that more than the Sigma now for long range shots as it's sharper than the 100-400 and the 150-500. If you only use the 100-400 occasionally you'd be as well off getting a 70-200 and 2x converter, then you have the best of both types, a fantastic medium zoom and a damn good long zoom.
 
Thanks guys your comments have been very helpfull.I think i will be going for the canon 70-200 f/2.8 is.As with everyone nowdays i suppose money is in short supply and with retirement looming im hoping this will propably be my last lens purchase.(fingers crossed)
 
Back
Top