I feel a bit of an idiot, but I need help with crop factors

Messages
2,145
Name
James
Edit My Images
No
I have been trying to read up on the difference between crop sensors and full frame sensors. The problem is I feel a bit stupid as I cant really understand in laymans terms what the end result to a picture is...

I have a canon 20D which as I understand it is a 1.6x crop factor and I really want to buy a Canon 5D MK2 which obviously is full frame.

Now, in terms of the 2 cameras, if I waws to place them side by side with say a 50mm prime lens on them and take a picture, what would be different (apart from one bieng a lot higher res).

Would it be that one image would appear to be "zoomed in?" ie. When you put your 50mm lens on a 20D, it becomes effectively a 80mm lens (50mmx1.6=80), with the reduced field of view that an 80mm lens it would appear zoomed?

So me in my uneducated head says, cant I just walk closer to the subject to achieve a (true) 50mm photo, rather than shell out for a full frame?

Sorry for the noob questions just a little confused...
 
Would it be that one image would appear to be "zoomed in?" ie. When you put your 50mm lens on a 20D, it becomes effectively a 80mm lens (50mmx1.6=80), with the reduced field of view that an 80mm lens it would appear zoomed?

Basically, this.
 
So me in my uneducated head says, cant I just walk closer to the subject to achieve a (true) 50mm photo, rather than shell out for a full frame?.

You'd walk further away, 1.6x further away and then subject would then be the same size on the sensor on both cameras.
 
The lens focal length does not change just because a lens is used on a different sized sensor-- just its angle of view from the lens to the sesnor. So the 5D will see the whole image with the 50mm, the 20D will see a crop of the image which will appear magnified, its frames as a 80mm image would look like on a FF sensor. Below links explains it better with pictures :D

http://www.cambridgeincolour.com/tutorials/digital-camera-sensor-size.htm
 
Would it be that one image would appear to be "zoomed in?" ie. When you put your 50mm lens on a 20D, it becomes effectively a 80mm lens (50mmx1.6=80), with the reduced field of view that an 80mm lens it would appear zoomed?

Yes.

So me in my uneducated head says, cant I just walk closer to the subject to achieve a (true) 50mm photo, rather than shell out for a full frame?

Yes.

Really, that's all there is to it. Some people like to try and complicate this - and in fact there is more advantages to full frame in terms of quality/low noise etc but for all intents and purposes, simply multiply your lens's focal length by 1.6 and you get the cropped focal length.
 
as pxl8 said you'd have to walk back rather than closer to get the same angle of view
 
This should help.....

crop-factor-photo.jpg
 
So me in my uneducated head says, cant I just walk closer to the subject to achieve a (true) 50mm photo, rather than shell out for a full frame?

If you look at it like that - just a matter of walking back and forth to alter framing - then there is no point in fitting different focal length lenses, or zoom lenses. It's called 'foot-zoom'. But even if you could do that all the time, perspective would change, so the picture would not look the same.

You use full frame because it has a bigger sensor, with all the addendant advantages (and disadvantages). The crop factor is mainly useful for comparing different focal lengths and equivalent fields of view on different formats. This is helpful for people used to 35mm film cameras (full frame) and a lot of lenses can be used on both crop format and full frame cameras, but obviously the field of view changes.

There are advanatges to using lenses primarily design to be used on one format or the other, hence Canon EF-S and EF lenses, Nikon DX and FX etc.
 
Back
Top