Is it better to desaturate PP or shoot in B&W mode?

Messages
6,914
Name
Damien
Edit My Images
Yes
Is there any advantages to either, selecting Black and White mode in camera (is this JPEG only or raw files aswell?), or shooting colour then desaturating or converting to black and white in PP?

I ask this because I had a (what could well turn out to be stupid) thought today that if a camera is only dealing with grey scale and not millions of different colours, the camera would "deal" with these files more efficiently, i.e. smaller files, higher fps, maybe even less noise!

Does the sensor change the way it performs because of the job it's being asked to do?:thinking:

I know if you shoot colour, you then have the option of leaving the image in colour, but I'm talking about specifically aiming for black and white images.....

Sorry if this is a stupid question but it's one of those things that will bug me if I don't find out the answer!!:cuckoo:
 
Shooting a B&W Jpeg fixes whatever B&W settings your camera is set to, (some cameras give you virtual coloured filters in B&W mode) fixed into the image.

If you're shooting only Jpeg, it's best to shoot in colour and convert in PP, as there are many different B&W conversion methods, which can give many differing results from the one coloured image.

If you shoot Raw or Raw+Jpeg, you can shoot with whatever B&W settings you want, be able to see an instant B&W image, but safe in the knowledge that if you don't like the results straight out of the camera, you have Raw data to convert to B&W, or save as a coloured Jpeg/Tiff to convert to B&W.

I'd rather have more options after the fact. ;) :)
 
HOW DO, selecting the option in the IN Camera menu is just like activating the in camera post processing. The CCD or CMOS sensor only outputs in one particular manner. The processor in the camera then looks at the data and converts it into a raw file. Activating the black and white function is just like switching on a post processing preset where the operator has little or no control. Far better results can be achieved in photo shop after the event. In real terms, more work is needed by the camera to turn out a B+W image.

Cheers

Willem
 
RAW is not a file type its the raw date from the sensor

Yeah, I knew that already!:naughty:

Jpg B&W with strip the colour and convert it into a B&W

That's new to me though!:thumbs: I always thought (for no good reason!) that when I selected B&W in camera, the sensor would only collect grey scale data, hence why I thought that fps might increase etc as the sensor would have less to do. I never once thought/realised that the conversion would happen after the sensor had done it's bit :bonk: even though it's REALLY obvious!

If you shoot Raw or Raw+Jpeg, you can shoot with whatever B&W settings you want, be able to see an instant B&W image, but safe in the knowledge that if you don't like the results straight out of the camera, you have Raw data to convert to B&W, or save as a coloured Jpeg/Tiff to convert to B&W.

Thanks for the tip!:thumbs:

The CCD or CMOS sensor only outputs in one particular manner.

Again, so obvious now I've had it pointed out to me!!:lol:

In real terms, more work is needed by the camera to turn out a B+W image

Which is the opposite of what I thought would be the case.........:$

Told you my "thought" would be a stupid one!!:lol:

Thanks for all the replies chaps/chapesses! Much appreciated!!
 
Yeah, I knew that already!:naughty:


That's new to me though!:thumbs: I always thought (for no good reason!) that when I selected B&W in camera, the sensor would only collect grey scale data, hence why I thought that fps might increase etc as the sensor would have less to do. I never once thought/realised that the conversion would happen after the sensor had done it's bit :bonk: even though it's REALLY obvious!
The reason for increased speed is the write time is shorter
 
well it's obvious to me but I wouldn't assume that it's obvious to everyone.

in a perfect world the sensor would somehow be able to sacrifice colour for monochrome tone. but they don't work like that. Another really obvious idea...like upping the ISO on the sensor but sacrificing megapixels. Something not often done. Not sure how good it is in practice either.

personally when I shoot B&W I want to know how it would come out, on the viewscreen...but not HAVE to use it in B&W or have the full options afterwards.
I shoot in RAW+JPG and apply the colour filter, sepia or B&W to the image on the camera.
then I can see the effect that I want, but the RAW image has all the colour that I can tweak later. however, RAW + Jpg doesn't exactly help with write/buffer performance!
 
well it's obvious to me but I wouldn't assume that it's obvious to everyone.

in a perfect world the sensor would somehow be able to sacrifice colour for monochrome tone. but they don't work like that. Another really obvious idea...like upping the ISO on the sensor but sacrificing megapixels. Something not often done. Not sure how good it is in practice either.

personally when I shoot B&W I want to know how it would come out, on the viewscreen...but not HAVE to use it in B&W or have the full options afterwards.
I shoot in RAW+JPG and apply the colour filter, sepia or B&W to the image on the camera.
then I can see the effect that I want, but the RAW image has all the colour that I can tweak later. however, RAW + Jpg doesn't exactly help with write/buffer performance!

Do you have to shoot raw + JPEG?
If I shoot raw with the camera set to B&W the display shows the embedded JPEG which is in B&W, no need to actually save a JPEG.

FWIW The sensor only measures the amount of light falling on it, not the colour. The sensor sites have coloured filters which changes how much light reaches the sensor site depending on the colour of the filter above that actual site. Not all cameras work the same - Google Bayer Filter for more detail.
 
By no means an expert myself, but I read somewhere that if you do decide to convert in PP (recommended by this particular article), don't just select 'desaturate'; there are better ways to convert to B&W using the colour information in the image to enhance contrast etc, rather than just throwing the colour information away.
 
Back
Top