Is there a price beyond which improvement in quality is negligible?

So there is a definite increase in quality? I don't mean just on close and careful analysis, but from even a cursory consideration?

I guess I'm just idly pondering whether it's similar to, say, high end audio. Cable manufacturers charge silly money for dubious technology that, time and time again, industry "experts" and hobbyists cannot distinguish from more basic alternatives in double-blind tests. Yet people shell out for it because it's held in high regard by the audio culture. They probably think they can hear a difference too.

But, like you say, perhaps it's a totally different thing. There's an objective difference that's significantly perceivable by the end user, and that's worth the extra cash.

No it's more like the difference between MP3 and FLAC. It's more data of better quality.

As I said though, it's all things being equal, the Hassy backs are not exactly on top of their game by some measures at the moment, but a larger sensor of similar quality to a smaller one should show an obvious quality improvement.
 
Might be worth mentioning you can do stuff with medium format that's practically impossible, or much more difficult, on 35mm.

Get a lens with a built-in leaf shutter and you can sync flash at much faster shutter speeds. Hasselblad H series lenses sync up to 1/800 sec, Mamiya 645 DF will sync at 1/1600 sec.

With a focal plane shutter, you're limited to about 1/250 sec tops. So you'll need a much more powerful lighting rig to overcome any ambient light.

e.g. This shot

http://www.bjp-online.com/british-journal-of-photography/test/1730996/hasselblad-h4d-camera-tested
 
Might be worth mentioning you can do stuff with medium format that's practically impossible, or much more difficult, on 35mm.

Get a lens with a built-in leaf shutter and you can sync flash at much faster shutter speeds. Hasselblad H series lenses sync up to 1/800 sec, Mamiya 645 DF will sync at 1/1600 sec.

With a focal plane shutter, you're limited to about 1/250 sec tops. So you'll need a much more powerful lighting rig to overcome any ambient light.

e.g. This shot

http://www.bjp-online.com/british-journal-of-photography/test/1730996/hasselblad-h4d-camera-tested


thats a pretty awful shot however lol
 
Nothing like that, I said that the 'quality' difference is dependent on the job it is used for. For example a D4 will produce better quality images at 12800iso than a MF because they aren't designed for that sort of work. However at 100iso in a studio the MF will be miles ahead in terms of quality.

Courious, I seem to remember all kinds of poor quality issues with medium format digital, there were lines, the fact that some of the sensors were actually made in two haves and each half being slightly different, yes they are better now but it's not always the case.
 
A professional chooses the right tool for the job

You are not going to deliver a huge generator in the back of a Mondeo, for that you need a truck

You are not going to want to drive for pleasure all over the continent for 8 weeks in a truck, for that you want a luxury car

You are not going to race a luxury car against a F1 car on a track, for that, you need a racing car..

It is exactly the same with cameras

If you want to travel the world and be incognito, a digital rangefinder might be the best camera

If you want to shoot weddings a crop or fullframe DSLR is usually just the ticket

If you are going to Bryce canyon, and shooting for the National geographic, a field camrea is just the job

If you are shooting a product or a model, and the image is to be displayed in a glossy mag, or on a bill board, or is going to be printed at 8foot square and put in an exhibition - then the medium format digital camera will be your probable weapon of choice


If you only have a MF digital, weddings are going to be hard work. If you only have a 35mm DSLR, most high end product / fashion shoots will be out of the question

If I shot high end fashion or product photography spending (or hiring) on a 20 - 50K camera makes complete business sense if i know it secures me a long string of 5K + jobs. Just like spending 3-5K on a camera for a successful wedding photographer is a no brainer.

This isn't a case of a better camera makes you a better photographer, any good professional will be able to use all of the cameras competently. It is more a case of choosing the right tool for the right job, and buying the right tool at the right time for the business cycle of work
 
But this is not about the best tool for the job is it. It is about the amount of difference in image quality from a £20000 camera versus a £1000 - £4000 camera.

And if there is any difference is it worth £15000+
 
As said before it's the law of diminishing returns, and it's applicable to a huge variety of items. Is it worth the extra will always be a user choice.

Is the hundreds of thousands spent in a wind tunnel to get that .001 of a second gain on a F1 car worth it, well yes to Ferrari, but would you or I really be worried if our ford focus was .001 faster no.

It's the same with HiFi to some that last little nuance of sound and clarity is worth the £50K spend on a amp or speakers, but if your only listening in your car or on an mp3 player, you'll not gain anything.

Same with photography, for the 99% of users printing no larger than A3 , £20K is not worth the money over a £4K camera, but for the very top end of the photography world were every teeny tiny bit of extra quality in needed/wanted then £20K is peanuts.
 
There is difference, Hasselblad produced slightly more details and color was more balanced to a girl skin tone. On a first sight the difference in image details seems to be so minimal that it will be hard to notice it. However, more I look at these images, more I see the difference in fine details: look at hair, areas under her eyes, etc. Twice as big 16 bit Hasselblad sensor delivers more texture and colors over 14 bit Nikon sensor. It is simply a matter of physics: 6 micron v.s 4.7 micron of a pixel size, and much larger sensor area along with additional color information (16 bit v.s 14 bit) makes a difference.

The Nikon can't compete at this level, but it isn't priced at the Hasselblad level and neither does it have optics at this medium format level to compete. We are always hearing how 'magical' full format is over crop sensors then you'd expect that same 'magic' to be be present in sensors 2x the size of full frame.
 
I once saw a sister that was A0 size taken by a hasselblad. The quality was amazing - sharpness was incredible.

I'm sure at lower resolutions you wouldn't spot much of a difference when a good body is coupled with decent glass...but I remember do looking at it thinking "wow".

Having said that, perhaps the D800 would compete?
 
I am impressed by the hassleblad. You can pick up a 2nd hand body and lenses for £2k, then a digital back for £7k. So very tempting..... If only I had £10k to blow on a new camera system :-)
 
But this is not about the best tool for the job is it. It is about the amount of difference in image quality from a £20000 camera versus a £1000 - £4000 camera.

And if there is any difference is it worth £15000+

You are 100% wrong. It is about best tool for the job. If you need to supply a huge clean detailed file, because that's what the client demands, then you need the top end camera. End of

Camera's at his level are purchased and used by professionals, and they know that the difference in quality, and file size is absolutely needed. This is not about gear snobbery. No business spends £20,000 to much on capital expenditure if it doesn't need to. Camera's at this level are 99% purchased because the business need dictates it

Photographers who use cameras like this, often will also shoot 35 MM DSLR for other jobs, where the jump in quality and file size is not needed.

Neither is this about diminishing returns, It is about weighing up - practical vs financial vs results

FWIW, you can now pick up a used 39MP Hasselblad with a lens on e-bay for under 6K. For a second camera (to a d3s), it would be something I would consider for certain types of wedding work
 
I am guessing you didn't read the OP?

I was just summarising what the OP had asked....

Problem is the question that was asked was too simplistic for the correct answer :)

The answer is the extra 15k is generally perceivable only to the people who need it to be, and most folk would not benefit from it one iota. Because it is about the right tool for the job and is much more than 'is it work 15k more'.
 
Problem is the question that was asked was too simplistic for the correct answer :)

The answer is the extra 15k is generally perceivable only to the people who need it to be, and most folk would not benefit from it one iota. Because it is about the right tool for the job and is much more than 'is it work 15k more'.

Okay, I will give you that one :)
 
... high end audio. Cable manufacturers charge silly money for dubious technology that, time and time again, industry "experts" and hobbyists cannot distinguish from more basic alternatives in double-blind tests. Yet people shell out for it because it's held in high regard by the audio culture. They probably think they can hear a difference too.

This caught my eye as I have a background in electronics and indeed one of the companies I used to work for made components for high end audio manufacturers. Anyway...

I think a good analogy is the performance of the Team GB cyclists in the recent Olympics. They had a policy of incremental improvement in all areas. If they thought they could get even a small advantage in any area they'd go for it as all the little changes in area after area add up and the final result was they won more medals than anyone else.

I'm pretty sure that with higher end camera gear sometimes the advantages are more basic, basically they can get an image that a full frame DSLR really can't match at the moment and if someone is flying you half way around the world to take a picture of something they may expect the best possible result so is a £20k+ camera worth it? If it puts food in your mouth and a roof over your head - yes.
 
This caught my eye as I have a background in electronics and indeed one of the companies I used to work for made components for high end audio manufacturers. Anyway...

I think a good analogy is the performance of the Team GB cyclists in the recent Olympics. They had a policy of incremental improvement in all areas. If they thought they could get even a small advantage in any area they'd go for it as all the little changes in area after area add up and the final result was they won more medals than anyone else.

I'm pretty sure that with higher end camera gear sometimes the advantages are more basic, basically they can get an image that a full frame DSLR really can't match at the moment and if someone is flying you half way around the world to take a picture of something they may expect the best possible result so is a £20k+ camera worth it? If it puts food in your mouth and a roof over your head - yes.


Exactly Alan, a very good analogy to use here - "Marginal gains", something which applies not just to elite athletes, but to high end equipment, whether it be audio visual, photographic, sports equipment, musical instruments.
The difference between a £20K top end camera and the ones costing ten times less, is like the difference between a custom made Fender or Gibson guitar and a basic off the shelf model from the same manufacturers.
 
Also agree it is completely about marginal gains.
Is it as simple as saying people who don't need, or maybe wouldn't really notice the gains, don't understand why someone else would pay £20k for an item when then can get one that is 90% as good for £2k ?
 
Back
Top