Jack of all trades - master of none!

Messages
1,590
Name
Brian Ardrey
Edit My Images
Yes
I see on some photographers websites that they 'specialise' in portrait, wedding, macro, landscape, architectural, sport and commercial. And looking at the websites, in many cases they certainly seem to be competent.

However...

Do you think this broad range of services is off putting to some customers?

Is it better to stick to one, or may be two closely related subjects? Even if you are actually competent on many types of photography.
 
Badger I think that it depends on if you Need to make a living or not ..
1 specialist subject is great, but unless very lucky - not practical:thinking:
 
Badger I think that it depends on if you Need to make a living or not ..
1 specialist subject is great, but unless very lucky - not practical:thinking:


I sort of agree with you but wonder if it puts some potential customers off. For example, if I was an architect, I think I would be put off if someone said they did weddings as well. Would it be sensible to market the different types of work you do separately?
 
I advertise as being a specialist in Wedding & Child Photography

For the simple reason that's what I specialise in :lol: clever eh !!!

However, I have had calendars printed with landscape stuff, and came joint 5th in an international landscape comp a few years back

I do see Pros who specialise in...

Landscape
Portrait
Weddings
Commercial
Everything...

:lol:

So you know they are taking the urine, and that devalues their services

DD
 
For the price of sites, it'd be worth setting up a few different sites, surely.. then each site would be perceived as specialist.

i.e. ???

mattyh-pressingthebutton.com

mattyh-atthepc.com

mattyh-deletingthecrap.com

mattyh-showinghisshots.com

mattyh-is-a-star.com

Are ALL specialist & available

:lol::lol::lol:

DD
 
I think it depends.

When I used to shoot weddings I had a separate wedding website, on which I mentioned that I also shoot fashion & commercial - no conflict there.

But if I had mentioned that I shot weddings on my commercial photography website my clients wouldn't have taken me seriously
 
I think it depends.

When I used to shoot weddings I had a separate wedding website, on which I mentioned that I also shoot fashion & commercial - no conflict there.

But if I had mentioned that I shot weddings on my commercial photography website my clients wouldn't have taken me seriously


Yes, I think that is the way round things are. It seems that industrial style togs are taken more seriously than those who do weddings.
 
Yes, I think that is the way round things are. It seems that industrial style togs are taken more seriously than those who do weddings.

Not sure where you get that from m8 :thinking:

Difficulty factor...

Tin of Baked Beans, Sofa, or

Wedding

Discuss.................. :shrug:

Totally different beasts

Garry's done both, so any input there will be interesting - Garry ???

DD
 
Not sure where you get that from m8 :thinking:

Difficulty factor...

Tin of Baked Beans, Sofa, or

Wedding

Discuss.................. :shrug:

Totally different beasts

Garry's done both, so any input there will be interesting - Garry ???

DD

I'm not saying I agree with it, but....

Its just that in my experience, I believe that people (not photographers) perceive wedding togs to be less competent in some types of work than industrial photographers. I don't know the reason for this.

As we know, weddings are possibly the most stressful type of work to do. And as far as competency goes, if you look at the work of the likes of Jeff Ascough, you will be hard pressed to find a more competent camera man than him.
 
Totally different beasts

Garry's done both, so any input there will be interesting - Garry ???

DD

Different beasts indeed. I have done both too and I found weddings much more stressful than say taking photos of buildings or fridges or piles of towels or backpacks for catalogues.
 
Not sure where you get that from m8 :thinking:

Difficulty factor...

Tin of Baked Beans, Sofa, or

Wedding

Discuss.................. :shrug:

Totally different beasts

Garry's done both, so any input there will be interesting - Garry ???

DD



Wedding photography is highly skilled in its own right, even though it requires little in the way of knowledge.

Advertising photography (fashion, sofa, polished wooden furniture, food, engineering etc) requires excellent knowledge of lighting, camera movements, basic physics, selling etc, very high standard of care but thes skills are mainly technical with a bit of artistry built in to the mix.

Baked beans by the way are quite difficult simply because it's such a prosaic subject. It's easy to photograph an exciting FMCG subject well, baked beans are FMCG but aren't as exciting as a McDonalds, even if they happen to be a 'better' product'(

Nothing's actually difficult, it's all about perception. Clients often regard wedding photographers as snapshooters and somehow not as professionals, whether or not that's fair is another matter - that's why I feel that if people do both, they need to keep the two types of business separate.
 
I suppose you could say that wedding toggery is about people skills above all else. A technically expert tog who rubs people up the wrong way will never be a successful wedding photographer.
 
Wedding photography is highly skilled in its own right, even though it requires little in the way of knowledge.

That's an interesting observation Garry. I know you well enough to know that there will be reason behind it. Can you explain your thinking on that for me ? I find the kind of wedding photography I aim to produce can be just as technically challenging as the tin of beans, especially at this time of year when you only have one go at it. At least the tin of beans isn't moving or crying! :)
 
That's an interesting observation Garry. I know you well enough to know that there will be reason behind it. Can you explain your thinking on that for me ? I find the kind of wedding photography I aim to produce can be just as technically challenging as the tin of beans, especially at this time of year when you only have one go at it. At least the tin of beans isn't moving or crying! :)

As I said, I regard it as highly skilled, it just doesn't require a high level of tech knowledge, compared to many other fields.

People skills, organisational skills, knowing how to make the best of whatever light is available, understanding DOF, avoiding camera shake, compositional skills, an unflappable nature, a good memory for faces and names, a good 'safety system' to avoid possible disasters, absolute familiarity with equipment, the ability to work under severe time pressures - these skills are hard to aquire and well beyond many people, but like the ability to squeeze a car through a narrow gap, or reverse well with a trailer, it has much more to do with skill and experience than with knowledge IMO
 
So are we agreeing that it is best to keep your advertised 'core skills' separate rather than advertise as a general purpose tog?
 
So are we agreeing that it is best to keep your advertised 'core skills' separate rather than advertise as a general purpose tog?
That's my experience
 
As I said, I regard it as highly skilled, it just doesn't require a high level of tech knowledge, compared to many other fields.

knowing how to make the best of whatever light is available, understanding DOF, avoiding camera shake, compositional skills, absolute familiarity with equipment, the ability to work under severe time pressures - these skills are hard to aquire and well beyond many people, but like the ability to squeeze a car through a narrow gap, or reverse well with a trailer, it has much more to do with skill and experience than with knowledge IMO

I thought you might say something along those lines, I think that absolute familiarity with the equipment I use and making the best of whatever light is available does take some knowledge though and if you add the time pressures that knowledge has to be instantly available. That perhaps where the skill is but it takes knowledge in the first place surely?
 
I think it depends.

When I used to shoot weddings I had a separate wedding website, on which I mentioned that I also shoot fashion & commercial - no conflict there.

But if I had mentioned that I shot weddings on my commercial photography website my clients wouldn't have taken me seriously

Completely agre with Gary on this one. The market does not take seriously people who claim to specialise in all forms, and Advertising photographerssneer at wedding and social photography whilst social photographers hold contemporary photography in sheer contempt sometimes.

So, like Gary, doing both is a difficult road to tread and I too had two websites. The really interesting thing as that those who approached me to do wedding photography loved my editorial work and did not want a traditional wedding photographer, or someone who only did weddings and portraits to do their wedding. They were absolutely model customers, left with a blank canvas (so what images would you really like on the day? Answer, just do what you do, we love your work........i'd die for such customers on a regular basis) and I produced some of my best work with such people.
 
I thought you might say something along those lines, I think that absolute familiarity with the equipment I use and making the best of whatever light is available does take some knowledge though and if you add the time pressures that knowledge has to be instantly available. That perhaps where the skill is but it takes knowledge in the first place surely?

I would guess garry is trying to say that although you need a fair bit of knowledge to do weddings, not as much as needed for the other types of togging
 
So are we agreeing that it is best to keep your advertised 'core skills' separate rather than advertise as a general purpose tog?

I'd also agree with the above. In my case I had to split my wedding and equine work as they don't really go hand in hand :D but in saying that I have picked up a fair few weddings from the equestrian side of the business and conversely have done a trash the dress shoot involving horses!

Some interesting points here about the perception of wedding 'togs from the commercial side of the business and not one I had ever considered or encountered.

Good thread! :thumbs:
 
I'd probably agree that advertising as a "general" photographer leaves you lost when compared to the specialists but strangely it's worked well for me. Of course a big difference is that I don't advertise apart from a small ad in the Yellow Pages so people can find the number.

I get asked by commercial clients about wedding work, wedding clients ask about event work, event clients ask about band photography and so on. I've tried hard to create a "brand" and it's worked well, people stop me and say "You're Shooting Pixels" and the feedback I get suggests that clients are happy and keen to mention my name whenever someone is looking for a photographer. I don't specialise in one area mainly because I'd get bored - I need variety to stay interested in the work so I'm happiest when each week is different from the last.
 
I'd probably agree that advertising as a "general" photographer leaves you lost when compared to the specialists but strangely it's worked well for me. Of course a big difference is that I don't advertise apart from a small ad in the Yellow Pages so people can find the number.
If it works for you, that's great.
Just to avoid any misunderstanding, I wasn't talking about advertising as such, my last actual advert was in Yellow Pages 8 years ago. It was a waste of money for me.
What I was talking about was identity. Separate websites, separate business cards

I get asked by commercial clients about wedding work, wedding clients ask about event work, event clients ask about band photography and so on.
I agree. My experience is that once people know me they're happy to ask me to do work in a different field.
I don't specialise in one area mainly because I'd get bored - I need variety to stay interested in the work so I'm happiest when each week is different from the last.
Again, this makes sense to me. I have a very low boredom threshold. I stopped wedding photography because of health problems, basically I did it because it was different, not for the extra money. Much the same for my studio tution, I like doing it and I like to see people making progress in studio photography, like wedding photography it can be more demanding than my commercial photography
 
Back
Top