Kinda disappointed with 50mm f/1.4 on the 5D today

Messages
929
Name
Lyle
Edit My Images
No
So was out shooting a few shots and whilst the quality is good if I shoot at 1.4 outside the shots had way too much light and looked washed out. The 550 always looked great on AF at the aperture but not the 5D.

I also took a few shots of my son in good light and his arm was blurred because he moved - I never had that issue with my 550 either, 1.4 was plenty quick enough.

I know the 5D is more of a pros camera so it may be that I need to be patient and work at it but wondered if anyone had any initial thoughts? Is it an issue with a setting on the camera?
 
What settings were you on? Did you have Shutter priority or manual set and not notice by any chance? I'm thinking the shutter speed was forced to be too long, causing the over exposure and the blur due to movement of your boy's arm.

Shooting with a f/1.4 wide open in good light would mean you need a really high shutter speed of about 1/1500 or even higher with ISO set at 100 since it it really is a huge aperture.
 
Last edited:
Yes, you need to tell us a bit more about your camera settings but go for T or Manual mode so you can crank up the shutter speed, Manual if you want to stay with the 1.4 aperture. ISO can go down below 200 too.

Going back to camera bodies, the 5D wipes the floor with the 550 so it's a matter of learning how to control camera and lens to make them do what you want.
 
Shooting with a f/1.4 wide open in good light would mean you need a really high shutter speed of about 1/1500 or even higher with ISO set at 100 since it it really is a huge aperture.

Without seeing the pictures and settings it's difficult to knw what the problem could be but a couple of things spring to mind...

At f1.4 in good light it's easily possible to hit 1/8000 second so care needs to be taken. This could account for the over exposed look.

As to the OOF arm, could it be due to shallow depth of field? With a 50mm lens on a 5D is it possibly that the shot was taken closer to your son and thus causing the DoF to be less than you got with the APS-C camera?
 
On a full frame sensor f/1.4 isn't really usable for anything other than arty DoF effects or shooting in the dark where a shallow DoF is preferable to no shot at all.

With my 50mm on full frame the lowest I will generally go when shooting people is f/2.8
 
were you using the same ISO on both cameras as if ISO was higher you could still top out the shutter speed.

Seeing the photo with the blurred arm or at least the EXIF data would help.
 
Thanks guys,

I just had it set on AF which, I thought, controller the shutter speed anyway. It always seemed ok on the 550d.

Not quite sure if I've understood what settings you were using. :shrug:

AF is Auto Focus. :shrug: It won't help with exposure.

Program mode should sort itself out and give pretty good exposures, as should Aperture and Shutter priority unless the light is extremely bright or dark, or the ISO was set on some really high setting.

Manual mode can give results like you've described. :shrug:
 
On a full frame sensor f/1.4 isn't really usable for anything other than arty DoF effects or shooting in the dark where a shallow DoF is preferable to no shot at all.With my 50mm on full frame the lowest I will generally go when shooting people is f/2.8

That's not really true though is it?

At f1.4 DoF is thin if you're close to your subject but once the camera to subject distance starts to increase so does DoF. At 20ft you'll be getting something like 4ft of DoF, by 30ft it'll be in the region of 10ft and after that it just gets... deeper. So, it really depends upon the distance you're stuck with/want/framing.
 
Tv = Shutter Priority
Av = Aperture Priority

Thanks, no idea why I put AF, I meant AV. I've checked the shot and it is indeed in AV mode which, in my understanding, took care of the shutter speed automatically.

I want to upload this shot with the attached exif. Can I do it through here or will I need to upload to Flickr or something?

Cheers,

JPJ
 
Thanks, no idea why I put AF, I meant AV. I've checked the shot and it is indeed in AV mode which, in my understanding, took care of the shutter speed automatically.

I want to upload this shot with the attached exif. Can I do it through here or will I need to upload to Flickr or something?

Cheers,

JPJ

Upload to Flickr and then link to here.

Av does indeed mean shutter speed is camera controlled.

Did you have ISO set to auto? Even though you were in Av, ISO can still be set manually.

Another avenue is if the metering was thrown off by somthing and its correcting influence was set to high. This is unlikely though.
 
Ok guys I've uploaded to Flickr with this shot I took minutes ago. I'm still having he blurring issue and I'm starting to worry I've bought a duffer! Please take a look for me guys and tell me what I'm doing wrong!

Blurry 5D shot

The shutter speed is far too low.
The subject moved.

Up your ISO and aim for a shutter speed above 1/200 when shooting in these conditions.

Try it now, you'll be amazed.
 
What Phil says.

Exif Data said:
Exposure 0.022 sec (1/45)
Aperture f/1.4
Focal Length 50 mm
ISO Speed 100
Exposure Bias +1 EV

1/45 is typicaly only slightly higher than what I use to achieve background motion blur on moving subjects.

I think your ISO may have been forced set into 100. You'd be surprised at how exceptional a camera your eye is. There is a lot less light than you think indoors and that is why when in Av mode the camera has set your shutter speed so low.

Check and set your ISO to Auto (of bump it up, like Phil said). This should allow the camera to use a higher shutter speed :)

Also of note is the exposure bias of +1, not sure if that is also a forced setting or not.
 
Last edited:
woo, thanks for the speedy reply. I have made those amends and yeah they have improved things.

Should AV not take care of ISO and shutter speed though?

Your ISO appears to be on manual, and you've set 100, even with a great lens like the 1.4 you will need at least 400 in a well lit room on a summers day, evenings upwards of 800.

AV will set your shutter speed, but only to get a correct exposure according to your choice of ISO and and the amount of available light.

The camera has no idea that you're shooting a toddler that may move about, many of us will allow a shutter speed that low or lower for specific reasons.

I think the problem here is that you're expecting the camera to read your mind, it takes lots of learning and practice even to learn everything you'll need to know. Have fun with it.
 
Okay, I've seen the upload photo - the colours are nice but I concur with what's already been said. A few additional suggestions though:

1. Bravo for getting your camera away from full Auto and trying to work out how to make it do things for you.

2. The flip side to this is that the more control you take, the more the camera needs inputs from you.

3. Digital cameras aren't cheap but, by golly, digital processing is a bargain. Get your camera and lens out, maybe wait 'til little one is abed so that you can concentrate and experiment with changing setting of ISO (rule of thumb: the less light there is, the bigger the ISO number needed.), shutter speed and aperture. Play with them one at a time first then see how you can recreate the same amount of light into the camera by upping ISO, slowing down shutter speed or opening the aperture wider.

4. Don't worry about either lens or camera being duff until you can control them fully.

5. There's another general rule of thumb about ensuring shutter speed is at least the same number as the lens diameter. Any shutter speed slower than 1/50th is going to be a struggle with a 50mm lens. This is about camera shake and your ability to hold things still. You'll already be thinking about how easily your images overexpose with your 50mm lens and an aperture anywhere near its maximum of f/1.4, which is the same thing as saying that a 50mm lens on 1/50 of a second will work in relatively low light levels. However...

6. 1/50th of a second is not quick enough when you're chasing your little man across the house. If you want him to be fully in focus, set Av to f/4.0, set ISO to full auto or take a brave ill and dial in 400 or 500 and see what happens. If shutter speed is still slow dial in more ISO.

7. Stick with it, you're making those first steps of learning how to use your camera. As you're not afraid to stick your head up and ask for help, I predict that in a few weeks' time you'll be making it jump and dance all over the place:clap::clap::clap:
 
Yes I did, like I used to on my 550 and it was always fine. I'm all for messing around with the manual settings but would like it to work as it did on the 550.

As has already been said, the camera doesn't necessarily know that you want a fast shutter speed. With using Auto ISO and Av, your asking the camera to do 2 things that may come into contradiction. Personally, I've only used Auto ISO in Shutter priority.
 
fabs said:
As has already been said, the camera doesn't necessarily know that you want a fast shutter speed. With using Auto ISO and Av, your asking the camera to do 2 things that may come into contradiction. Personally, I've only used Auto ISO in Shutter priority.

Interesting...

I'll learn a little more about ISO then. It's just something I haven't considered too much on the past. Do you guys generally keep it high?
 
Interesting...

I'll learn a little more about ISO then. It's just something I haven't considered too much on the past. Do you guys generally keep it high?

It very much depends on what I'm shooting so I need to take into account the depth of field I need and the shutter speed required. The ISO is set so that I can get the correct exposure with those settings.

With sport, for example, I need a fast shutter speed therefore a high shutter speed is required. Say I need a speed of 1,000th of a second, I'd probably need to open the aperture to no narrower than f4, preferably f2.8 to achieve that, depending on the light available. If it's a bright day, then ISO100 may be enough. On a dull day though, I may need to raise it to 800 or even 1600.

If you're using AV and shooting something/someone fast moving, set your aperture to a wide setting, but not as wide as f1.4 as trying to nail focus with that narrow a depth of field is extremely difficult. Try something like f4 and see what shutter speed you get, then raise the ISO until you achieve a speed fast enough to capture what you want nice and sharp.
 
It very much depends on what I'm shooting so I need to take into account the depth of field I need and the shutter speed required. The ISO is set so that I can get the correct exposure with those settings.

With sport, for example, I need a fast shutter speed therefore a high shutter speed is required. Say I need a speed of 1,000th of a second, I'd probably need to open the aperture to no narrower than f4, preferably f2.8 to achieve that, depending on the light available. If it's a bright day, then ISO100 may be enough. On a dull day though, I may need to raise it to 800 or even 1600.

If you're using AV and shooting something/someone fast moving, set your aperture to a wide setting, but not as wide as f1.4 as trying to nail focus with that narrow a depth of field is extremely difficult. Try something like f4 and see what shutter speed you get, then raise the ISO until you achieve a speed fast enough to capture what you want nice and sharp.

Thanks Fabs, very much appreciate you taking the time to explain that. I'm so used to my 550d doing all this for me!
 
I think one of the biggest things you did wrong was have the +1 of exposure compensation dialled.

When you look through the view finder you will see a meter, 0 in the middle +'s to one side and -'s to the other.

Pay attention to this because by dialling in +1 you are forcing the camera to over expose, which it will do by increasing the shutter speed. Try putting it back to 0 and your shutter speed will go up and your images wont looked so washed out.
 
The 5D doesn't have Auto ISO... so you will need to set that manually when shooting in Av, Manual or Tv modes :thumbs:

All the other advice is spot on :thumbs:
 
Is that definitely the case leftcurl? It has an auto option?

Your title says 5d, Leigh is right, the 5d has no auto ISO.

However, According to your details you have a 5d mkII, which has auto ISO.
 
Back
Top