Loch Harray Sunset...mark 2

[Andysnap]

Evenin' All,

I know I've already posted a similar image to this one but I believe this to be an improvement. I'll post them both so you can judge.

Please let me know what you think, any help is always gratefully recieved.

Cheers

Andy

1. The Original

2. The (hopefully) New and Improved Version

 

[Andysnap]

Damn, now I've seen them together I'm not sure it is an improvement. The second looks a little too bright. :bang:

Andy

 

[rh1944]

I think I prefer your dark and moody self. More atmosphere for me.

 

[Andysnap]

I've just printed them both out and the second one looks fantastic (even though I says so meself). The original is too dark when printed but may look better on screen. Oh I don't know, this photography larks getting very complicated.

Andy

 

[erding]

Prefer the original. The focal points of the image are the sunrays through the cloud and the reflection on the water - impact of both of these have been lost in the edit

 

[BRASH]

Have to say I prefer No 1. The darker version makes it more atmospheric. Still both nice enough