My first post for criticism - tree

[Shane]

Hi, this is my first post for comments and criticism

One of our college projects is trees.

1. Original Shot

2.

3.

Thanks

 

[Susane]

Number 2 for me, little boost to the levels would be good as it looks a little flat and a little more saturation too.

 

[Shane]

Number 2 for me, little boost to the levels would be good as it looks a little flat and a little more saturation too.

Thanks.

How about.... No. 4

 

[sawman]

No2 for me too! There might have been some interesting patterns on the trunk of that old girl.

 

[Susane]

Thanks.

How about.... No. 4

Yes, that's heading in the right direction.

 

[CT]

No 2 with a bit less saturation than No 4, but more contrast please.

 

[dellipher]

Well done looking good I like no 2....and no 4 hehe

 

[Shane]

No 2 with a bit less saturation than No 4, but more contrast please.

No. 5

 

[Messiah Khan]

Somewhere between 4 and 5 for me.

 

[deanlewis]

Nice shot, No.5 for me with a little less saturation.

Deano

 

[Gresh]

TBH, I prefer number 4. A lot of Texture, looks good.

 

[InaGlo]

Somewhere between 4 and 5 for me.

Yup, for me too!

 

[marky_h]

Somewhere between 4 and 5 for me.

[S4]I agree - just needs a little more subtlety[/S4]

 

[Shane]

Thanks for the feedback , its good to get some real comments.

 

[Mohain]

Not bad at all! I'm quite partial to the mono version, might need a bit more contrast tho?

 

[sujay]

I think I like no 4, but I am no expert, I just like what I see.