Photgraphing people at a private event for portfolio

Messages
586
Name
Steve
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi all,

At our annual Charity fundraising ball we take photos of guests for use on our own website and publication in local magazines/newspapers. The Ball is by ticket only and on private property. No money is made from publication of these images so I believe this is all OK.

A local photography student has asked if she can attend this year to take candid photographs of guests, for her to use in her personal portfolio.
She will also provide copies of these for our use as a "thanks". She has taken photos at recent music festivals and posted these on her publicly accessible Facebook account (this includes images of children and adults) for which I can only assume she received permission if she needs it. She intends to do the same with pictures from our Ball.

Can you more experienced people please advise if we are OK to allow her to do this? :thinking:
I.e. does she need to get model releases from guests etc, or do we need a contract of some sort with her?

Many thanks!
Steve
 
A release (for editorial or artistic or newsworthy use) would not normally be required where the photographs are created in either a public place or a place where photography is not prohibited by the siteholder - however if there is commercial intent (such as if they were used to advertise something, or sent to a stock agency) then a release is necessary, though I think there are some allowances for 'crowd scenes' where there are no specifically prominent or identifiable individuals. If you are using images of identifiable individuals to promote the charity on its website then I presume the release is built into the terms of entry and the guests are aware that there is a photographer present for that purpose.

It is not really about whether money is made from publication of the images, it's generally OK to publish and indeed sell images for newsworthy or artistic purposes - it's the association between a person or their property and a product or service which would normally require permission of some kind. In your case the guests may be consenting to their likeness being used in connection with the charity via the conditions of entry and their knowledge that photographs are being taken for that purpose. As far as the student goes, I think she needs to understand the usage limitations.
 
What makes me a little uncomfortable about this *type* of request is how the photographer can use the images to imply to that they were commissioned by the Personality to shoot the portraits.

Just this week I've found the website of a photographer local to me who's showing portrait-style images of two TV presenters on their home page. They're not bad images truth be told but close inspection leads me to think they were shot at public events (ie roadshow/ live versions of the TV programs).

Maybe it's not up to you to morally police the student's approach to business- after all, if this is what s/he plans to do it's pretty entrepreneurial- but it could affect your event's future success if one of the visitors catches wind of what's going on.
 
I don't think this is really a problem for you, any guest at the event could take photos and plaster them all over facebook themselves.

IF this student did try and make financial gain or display the photo in a way that's derogatory to the person in it then it would be her that'd cop the flack for it.
 
Good post from Lindsay (and some great pics on the website :thumbs:).

But the question for me is not a legal one at all, but more of a moral issue. And that is, how would the guests feel about it?

Being photographed like this, quite possibly in unflattering candid situations, by someone with 'a big camera' is not the same as other guests snapping away with their compacts and mobiles. And you have no control about how the images will be used later.

If I was attending a private event, which this is, as a guest I would expect it to be private. But as a photographer, I also know there could be some interesting images to be had. Not easy!
 
Thanks for the replies. :) I'm in agreement with the last comment especially about the private matter so we've decided to decline and invite her to a more public event.
 
Back
Top