Portrait shooters - eyes out of focus with 1.4?

Messages
837
Edit My Images
No
Currently using a D200 with Nikon 50mm 1.4 (Non D) lens. Frustrating thing is when taking portraits at anything from 1.4-2.8 the eyes only seem to be pin sharp a fraction of the time. Now this isn't because of the lens not being sharp at 1.4 / wide open - it is very sharp! So I've concluded that it can either b A) User error or B) Camera mis/front focussing.

I always focus on the eyes then recompose as little as I can, but I find that I have this problem whether I recompose or not so I don't think its to do with shallow DoF. The eyes only fill part of the focus bracket as I'm not that close - and from what I understand the the focus sensors are pretty big, bigger than the bracket and a lot bigger than the eye you're trying to focus on. So I imagine it'd be pretty hard for the camera to know to focus on the eye when theres other parts of the face in the focus sensor. Most shots seem to be front focussing or the eyes aren't pin sharp (which I know IS possible).

It's bloody frustating- using the 18-200 everything is sharp where I want it to be (but the 5.6 aperture could be compensating) - so I'm pretty sure that its not the body thats front focussing.

My questions are: Does anyone else find this with fast prime portrait lenses? If so how do they overcome it? Focus on something a little further on and hope its in focus? Or does it sound like my camera / lens combo is not working properly? This is driving me crazy as I find myself not being able to trust the camera to get sharp shots for portraits!
 
My questions are: Does anyone else find this with fast prime portrait lenses? If so how do they overcome it?

Practice - practice then practice some more. It is not easy to get consistently sharp focus at 1.4 but it can be done!
 
Firstly, why are you shooting at f:1.4? Usually, unless you're shooting the subject face on only one eye with be sharp at f:1.4. You won't get the best from the lens anyway, atop down to f:2.8, you'll still get nice blurred backgrounds, you've more chance of getting the focus spot on, plus the lens is working closer to its comfort zone so the reults will be better.

Secondly, the margin for error is small at f:1.4. It could be something as simple as your subject moving, you moving, or a combination of both. Test the lens tripod mounted on a static subject to see whether the lens or body has issues.
 
Firstly, why are you shooting at f:1.4? Usually, unless you're shooting the subject face on only one eye with be sharp at f:1.4. You won't get the best from the lens anyway, atop down to f:2.8, you'll still get nice blurred backgrounds, you've more chance of getting the focus spot on, plus the lens is working closer to its comfort zone so the reults will be better.

Secondly, the margin for error is small at f:1.4. It could be something as simple as your subject moving, you moving, or a combination of both. Test the lens tripod mounted on a static subject to see whether the lens or body has issues.

I like the feel of wide apertures, 1.4 to me is pretty dreamy - and when I do I am shooting them straight on. But I've been using 1.4 in low light when I don't want to use flash - and this is when the in focus shots seems to drop to about 10-20%! :|

I've tried 'test' shots using static subjects and steady supports, I seem to get accurate focus and sharp shots only about 50% of the time (with my 50mm Non D - it seems to be whirring and shifting focus everytime I refocus). With my AF-S 18-200 lens it pretty much hits 99% of the time. (Is this pointing towards hardware problems?)

But even with 2.8 focus seems feels pretty hit and miss - and as I've normally only used slow lenses I was wondering if this is normal for wide lenses - or is it pointing more towards a dodgy body / lens combination?
 
As stated above test the focus by using the camera/lens on a steady tripod on a static subject - if all looks good then - you really just need to practice.
 
Don't focus and re-compose, select a different af point instead. You don't have to move much to miss focus at f/1.4... you want to try f/1.2!

awp is right in that practice and more practice can help a lot. And Northern Nikons comments hold true as well, you need to know if it's you or a camera issue. It's probably more likely to be user error which is actually a good thing... you can fix that a lot easier!

cheers
 
Do people not find that the auto focus areas are too large? (On my d200 anyway)

Even if I'm fairly close, sometimes the camera locks onto eyelashes rather than the eye itself?! Seems like it's difficult to be totally selective on the area you want to focus on! Are there any cameras with small AF sensors?!
 
Do people not find that the auto focus areas are too large? (On my d200 anyway)

Even if I'm fairly close, sometimes the camera locks onto eyelashes rather than the eye itself?! Seems like it's difficult to be totally selective on the area you want to focus on! Are there any cameras with small AF sensors?!


Well... I can't really speak for Nikons being a Canon user myself. But I'd guess the only other option is manual focus. I've done plenty of that in the days when you had no choice... AF is more consistent :)
 
Well... I can't really speak for Nikons being a Canon user myself. But I'd guess the only other option is manual focus. I've done plenty of that in the days when you had no choice... AF is more consistent :)

On the Canon you use, when taking portraits, does the eye fill the AF bracket? Or is it smaller than the AF bracket? I'm starting to actually think that the AF is picking up detail around the eye (as the bracket is actually wider than you think) and is focussing on that rather what's in the middle of the bracket?
 
I would think it's smaller on the Canon, probably the same with the Nikon.
To be honest there's a certain amount of luck involved too, but I still think AF is more consistent than manual focus. I'm also convinced that manual focus is actually MORE accurate if you could guarantee that neither you or the subject would move even a fraction of an inch. But of course in practice this is almost impossible. And even the best of current DSLR's have lousy viewfinders compared to the old film cameras. If you don't believe me have a look through an Olympus OM1 viewfinder... you'll be amazed at the difference.

I'd suggest taking lots of shots. In a sense it's totally the wrong thing to do, because you should know that your camera/lens combination is spot on for focus... and it is you could get away with just one shot (you'd be a lot better than I could ever aspire to). But in the real world maybe it's not quite as simple as that :) And it's the real world that we actually live in.

I don't know if that helps any? But we should never stop trying should we...

cheers
 
I love shooting at f1.4. The biggest issue is simply movement. If you even move a FRACTION after focusing, it's gonna show. You need to focus and instantly shoot, even then it can still miss. Best bet is to take lots of "safety shots".

Remember that parts of the face will be OOF at f1.4 too.

See this set for some f1.4 playing:
http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=155540

Gary.
 
I would guess it's probably a user-focus issue. You have no more than 20mm depth of field with a head and shoulders at f/1.4. Easy to move that much with focus/recompose. You and your subject will also move quite a few mm just by breathing.

You also mention it happens in low light - maybe some camera shake creeping in?

It's easy enough to check the camera for accuracy with a static subject.
 
Just a thought: you are using the camera on 'C' - continuous focus arn't you?
 
Just a thought: you are using the camera on 'C' - continuous focus arn't you?

If he was then he would be having problems by recomposing.
 
If he was then he would be having problems by recomposing.

I personally think it's almost impossible to lock focus in and recompose using f1.4. I just can't see how it's doable, there is so little room for maneuver.

What I do, is use a single focus point, and which one depends on the composition I want. Worse case, I may need to slightly alter the crop in PP.

Gary.
 
I'm not using continuous focussing - I would lock focus then shift slightly. I think this was contributing to the problem! But after several hours of messing about, I think I've found out the main cause - as I suspected before, it was lack of knowledge of the size/area of the AF brackets.

On the D200, the AF 'strips' extend far beyond the bracket. On testing with a blank piece of paper and a single line, the camera would lock focus even when the line wasn't in the bracket, but beyond the border of the bracket. This test allowed me to map the AF sensors on the D200, and they are considerably beyond the brackets marked. And then when drawing two parallel lines and shot at a 45 degree angle, putting one in the AF 'bracket' and the other one outside (but still within reach of the AF strip) the D200 would focus perfectly on the closer line, even when one line was in the bracket and the other outside it.

Which will lead me to my own conclusion that this particular D200 (and possibly all of them) will prioritise focus to objects that are closest in its AF sensors, even if you place a prominent object bang in the middle of one and there's a closer one on the verge of the sensor...

So lessons learned - map the AF sensors when using fast lenses - the extra DoF tends to hide any discrepencies with slower lenses, so fast lenses really highlight mistakes. Now everytime I shoot, I'm using the edge of the brackets to focus - it is quite a pain, but I'm sure I'll get used to it until I upgrade the body....sharpness has now greatly improved! But it does mean I have to think a LOT when focusing, I can't just snap away.
 
I personally think it's almost impossible to lock focus in and recompose using f1.4. I just can't see how it's doable, there is so little room for maneuver.

What I do, is use a single focus point, and which one depends on the composition I want. Worse case, I may need to slightly alter the crop in PP.

Gary.

With 'only' 11 points on the D200, single point focus without recomposing isn't really an option unless you crop which I'm not a fan of...and I still don't really trust the side sensors due to them not being cross-points (I probably need to 'map' them out too), I guess it's a lot easier with 51 points! But I definitely agree, thinking about it now at 1.4 recomposing and keeping it sharp is gonna be damn near impossible...which probably explains the OOF shots!
 
Compose > Focus > Click. That's the way I have always done portraits. There is a fair bit written about autofocus and it's errors. Here is a test chart. The short answer is to manual focus. I've often thought with the advent of digital, the abolition of the visual split screen aid a mistake. Now that we are seeing the return of the full 35 mm frame in greater numbers, we might also see the return of the split screen as standard, or at least a low cost user installed option.
 
lock onto an eye....the nearest if so
then recompose
you may be composing without focussing on the discrete area which you want in focus
this works on my digita
slight pressure on the shutter release will focus

focus>compose>click...;)
 
lock onto an eye....the nearest if so
then recompose
you may be composing without focussing on the discrete area which you want in focus
this works on my digita
slight pressure on the shutter release will focus

focus>compose>click...;)

Recomposing at f1.4 is extremely difficult with Auto Focus, it really is. The SLIGHTEST of movement can render your focal point OUT of focus, so I always ensure at silly apertures, I focus on the way to the click.

Gary.
 
Compose > Focus > Click. That's the way I have always done portraits. There is a fair bit written about autofocus and it's errors. Here is a test chart. The short answer is to manual focus. I've often thought with the advent of digital, the abolition of the visual split screen aid a mistake. Now that we are seeing the return of the full 35 mm frame in greater numbers, we might also see the return of the split screen as standard, or at least a low cost user installed option.

I don't recommend that test chart. It is inappropriate, critical to the point of irrelevance and very prone to user errors. It creates problems were none exists. There are much better and easier ways (I've posted suggestions loads of times before) ;)
 
Recomposing at f1.4 is extremely difficult with Auto Focus, it really is. The SLIGHTEST of movement can render your focal point OUT of focus, so I always ensure at silly apertures, I focus on the way to the click.

Gary.


no it isnt...when you lock the focus on the eye...its locked
you can point the camera at your feet....it is still focussed on the eye's distance

at least on mine it is...and that is what olympus recommend
this applies for spot metering as well
do you want to see and example:|

edit...gary auld reekie old chap...what do you mean by the click...i think we may be talking the same thing but me being from boness cant understand you
cheers
geof
 
When you recompose, the distance to subject changes slightly especially if the camera is rotated...possibly less so if the camera is moved exactly 'sideways'...so even when recomposing after focus lock, there will probably be some loss of sharpness.

Edit: I used the wrong word - I meant 'distance' instead of focus.
 
I gave up with very wide apertures and have settled on 2.8 or more. I don't personally like it when one eye is sharp and the other blurred. It is best used for creativity and in controlled circumstances. Just be ready to be surprised by the results one way or the other.

Graham
 
When you recompose, the focus is shifted slightly especially if the camera is rotated...possibly less so if the camera is moved exactly 'sideways'...so even when recomposing after focus lock, there will probably be some loss of sharpness.

thats cool!!

the eye is still the same distance away...just in a different part of the lens sighting. measured radially..but i do agree...there must be some difference
 
I mistyped what I meant so I've edited my post - but just to confirm when you do recompose, due to the rotation and movements of the focal plane, the distance to the subject may no longer be the same.

Edit: Heres a link that may be of interest: Focus and Recomposing - why it sucks
 
I mistyped what I meant so I've edited my post - but just to confirm when you do recompose, due to the rotation and movements of the focal plane, the distance to the subject may no longer be the same.

:D

will it be closer or farther away...dof etc...:razz:
 
I don't recommend that test chart. It is inappropriate, critical to the point of irrelevance and very prone to user errors. It creates problems were none exists. There are much better and easier ways (I've posted suggestions loads of times before) ;)
But none the less, does show or demonstrate that auto focus is not perfect, errors are more likely to be apparent at f1.4. With such limited depth of field it's pushing the technology to (beyond) its limits. ;)
 
how about taking three shots and chosing one which seems a bit better than the other two
distance from the 'eye' can have some bearing as can the focal length of the lens
 
I personally think it's almost impossible to lock focus in and recompose using f1.4. I just can't see how it's doable, there is so little room for maneuver.

What I do, is use a single focus point, and which one depends on the composition I want. Worse case, I may need to slightly alter the crop in PP.

Gary.


I quite agree (1.4 is a bit silly really), that focussing and shooting in one go is probably the only way to work with such a small aperture, but if he needs to recompose for the shot he wants then continuous focus will blow out his selected focus point.
 
Back
Top