Shadow of the Tree

[canonbabie]

Hi,

Just experimenting with the camera and settings.

Cheers.

 

[alfbranch]

Well its not a shadow is a silhouette and it doesnt work for me, you have not isolated it from the ground and there is too much sun showing and not enough light tones for me.

 

[canonbabie]

Well its not a shadow is a silhouette and it doesnt work for you have not isolated it from the ground and there is too much sun showing and not enough light tones for me.

Yes the Title is probably wrong, but the image wasn’t captured for you and as stated it was just an experiment.

 

[alfbranch]

Yes the Title is probably wrong, but the image wasn’t captured for you and as stated it was just an experiment.

So why post it in the critique section?
Or why post it at all?

 

[canonbabie]

So why post it in the critique section?
Or why post it at all?

Why not?

 

[alfbranch]

Why not?

Then be prepared for critique!

 

[canonbabie]

Then be prepared for critique!

Your critique is more like craptique.

 

[sirch]

Pulling up a comfy chair for this one

 

[Tom Pinchenzo]

Your critique is more like craptique.

This thread is fun. Also, 'craptique', that's my kinda come-back.

 

[alfbranch]

Your critique is more like craptique.

I have amended my Craptique to correct an error and stand by it

 

[canonbabie]

I have amended my Craptique to correct an error and stand by it

A Good craptique is hard to come by, I normally sit down for mine not stand.

 

[mrtoad]

Pulling up a comfy chair for this one

ho hum earwig go

 

[LongLensPhotography]

I'll just say this - if you own a printer try printing it very big quite a few times

 

[alfbranch]

Why not?

Why did you post this photo as you have not stated why so far.
If experiment with my camera set to g I do not post the results publicly unless I want opinions.

As I have said it does not work for me compositionally or with the tones presented. It just looks underexposed so what were you aiming for?

Or why didn't you post it in photos for pleasure?