Taking photos of buildings against overcast sky

Messages
82
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi all

I'm brand new to the DSLR world. I have a question relating to taking photos op buildings (or other structures) against a overcast background. When I try to take a photo of the building and the sky forms part of my composition, the building turns dark (probably because of the whitish sky). How to I overcome this problem.

Thanks
 
Sounds like you are exposing for the sky and not the building.

Either meter on the building or use some exposure compensation to lengthen the exposure although that will tend to blow the sky
 
Hi all

I'm brand new to the DSLR world. I have a question relating to taking photos op buildings (or other structures) against a overcast background. When I try to take a photo of the building and the sky forms part of my composition, the building turns dark (probably because of the whitish sky). How to I overcome this problem.

Thanks

Welcome soliberus :)

Common problem. The camera has to make certain assumumtions in order to 'guess' at correct exposure - that is all it can do. Basically, if it sees a lot of bright area in the picture, it tends to think the whole image is bright, and reduces the exposure. It doesn't know you want a picture of the building, and not the sky.

So check the LCD, which will be confirmed by the histogram (see handbook). Correct it by adding some 'plus' exposure compensation.

What camera are you using and what exposure mode? Are you set on evaluative/matrix metering? If so, I'm surprised that the camera is not smart enough to get closer to optimum than it sems to be doing. Check your settings.
 
Hi HoppyUK

The problem I've explained is from my experience with compact cameras/camcorders.

I bought a Nikon D40 with the 18-55mm kit lens.

I haven't had the opportunity yet to go out and test it out on buildings on an overcast day, but I wanted to know what settings I have to change should it pull the same stunts as the compact camera when it comes to getting the exposure wrong.

Would it be possible to set the exposure by pointing at the building (no sky in the composition), lock the exposure and then recompose the frame (by including the sky)?
 
Hi HoppyUK

The problem I've explained is from my experience with compact cameras/camcorders.

I bought a Nikon D40 with the 18-55mm kit lens.

I haven't had the opportunity yet to go out and test it out on buildings on an overcast day, but I wanted to know what settings I have to change should it pull the same stunts as the compact camera when it comes to getting the exposure wrong.

Would it be possible to set the exposure by pointing at the building (no sky in the composition), lock the exposure and then recompose the frame (by including the sky)?

Yes, that's the easy way. Sorry I forgot to mention it, but try matrix metering on your D40. It's pretty damn clever :)
 
When you have an overcast sky what you will find is that the sky is your light source and, compared to everything on the ground it will be very bright. I think it is usually best to avoid shooting your subject and straight into its light source at the same time, if possible. There are options you can consider though....

- Find a different angle that puts the brightest part of the sky behind you and the dimmest part in front of you;
- Shoot multiple exposures, one to capture detail in the sky, one to capture detail in the subject, then combine them in software;
- Use a graduated or split neutral density filter to subdue the sky while keeping the foreground brighter;
- Shoot raw, with an exposure carefully set to hold detail in the sky, with the foreground going dim, then use your raw software to brighten the foreground.

Here is an example where changing the angle made quite a difference....

Good angle, no edits :
20071020_130303_0029_LR.jpg


Terrible angle, shot 2 minutes later, no edits :
20071020_130520_0030_LR.jpg


Here's one where I shot to hold sky detail, deliberately underexposing the foreground, no edits....

20071130_112150_0405_LR.jpg


Here it is after a bit of tweaking in Lightroom :

20071130_112150_0405_LR.jpg
 
With apologies/thanks to Tim, here's one of his photos with contrast mask script applied in my image editor:
tdodd-edit.jpg
 
With apologies/thanks to Tim, here's one of his photos with contrast mask script applied in my image editor:

Apologies I think ;)
 
Back
Top