Tell the government what you think about photographers being harrassed

S44 (I think) of the terrorism act, the one the police currently use to hassle photographers, has already been deemed illegal by the European Courts, but our illustrious govt. has decided to continue using it for the time being.
 
What I think of S44 doesn't bear repeating.
 
The funny thing about S44 is the appeal that the govt. used to keep using the power failed as well. S44 is illegal under Human Rights laws, it's just a shame that the Home Office have decided to keep using it despite what Europe have said.
 
The funny thing about S44 is the appeal that the govt. used to keep using the power failed as well. S44 is illegal under Human Rights laws, it's just a shame that the Home Office have decided to keep using it despite what Europe have said.

Can't have it both ways - you can't say 'Its European Law' when it suits us and then claim sovereignty over European Law when it doesn't.
For economic reasons we are part of the EU, but key elements of UK Law and our monetary system remain separate...
That's why the Government can decide to ignore Brussels on things like this.

The Law as it stands is fine in my opinion - it's the implementation of that Law that is flawed, specifically with regard to Police and PSCO officers not knowing what they can and cannot detain individuals for under S44...
The fact that there appears to be no method of ensuring officers are up to date on current guidelines issued by their own Police Force is of some concern to me.
 
The Law as it stands is fine in my opinion - it's the implementation of that Law that is flawed, specifically with regard to Police and PSCO officers not knowing what they can and cannot detain individuals for under S44...
The fact that there appears to be no method of ensuring officers are up to date on current guidelines issued by their own Police Force is of some concern to me.

Spot on :thumbs: indeed it is worrying particularly when you've had personal experience of it, the plod really do need some sort of guidelines about discretion on this issue.
 
the whole thing is farce

We have journalists snapping outside 10 Downing street, catching a copy of a secret brief, in the policemans hand. We have CCTV cameras down just about every street, watching people, cars, bus lanes. controlled by... the police - nope - in the main private security gaurds and council run enforcement companies

We have the National Trust banning "professional looking" cameras on their land (or is that "our land" that they look after)

In most cases the determination of what is not liked is wooly i.e. "professional looking equipment, tripods & the like". Meanwhile we have kids running about with 8mp camera phones who remain unchallenged

If photography is "banned" then use of all cameras including phones, CCTV, pinhole, compacts, holgas, SLR's, DSLR's, video cameras, sneaky compacts also need banning

The anti-terrorism thing is a joke - when in the main all you need to get a decent street plan with photo's is google earth and google street view and a laptop

The reason terrorists were so successful with 911, is that they thought outside the box, and then coordinated efforts

Look at the raft of measures that have been brought in since 911 - however none of them deal with the blatantly obvious - hiring a private jet for example

targeting photographers with the terrorism act is patently ridiculous. If a terrorist has a brain they can easily bring a country's infrastructure down easily, without going for anything high profile at all. Al they need to do is attack the water supply, or power supply, or sererage or transport networks, to cause major problems with minimal efforts

What we are seeing is essentially for show - that is police in high profile areas showing that they are the boss, to send out a message that they are not taking any messing about. Often it is the humble photographer at the brunt of the message
 
Richard

I agree with you totally bar one thing

We have the National Trust banning "professional looking" cameras on their land (or is that "our land" that they look after)

This is not true mate, some houses do but the rules changed at the beginning of this year.

I carry a Gripped 5D2 with L glass and have only been asked not to photograph certain rooms, which is sensible for many reasons.

As to " We own the land " unless your a paid up member ( I am ) you own nothing. The National trust is a trust and has nothing to do with taxes.

The last year since rules changed has been a breath of fresh air in the Trust, and I think they know it.

:D
 
Back
Top